Limitations of Photography in Portraying War Realities

773 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: How media effects war

Photography plays a huge role when it comes to documenting history and capturing significant moments of war. But can pictures especially war pictures really portray experience and hidden emotions that a human being has gone through? Many soldiers are diagnosed with PTSD after their service and they are left with the painful memories of battle to the point where hearing the word “combat” bring tears to their eyes. Not only that but sometimes the images we see may even be censored to cover up what the government does not want to be shown. Although photography can give an image of how war is perceived, it is not dependable for presenting the concealed side like censorship and chaos. Photography may be seen as a helpful tool in recording history, history itself cannot be based on images. Susan Sontag author of “ Regarding the Pain of Others”, states:
What the American military promoted during the Gulf War in 1991 were images of the techno war: the sky above the dying, filled with light-traces of missiles and shells- images that illustrated America’s absolute military superiority over its enemy. American …show more content…

Fear and panic conquers over especially when things like a bomb go off unexpectedly. In “Soldier Stories”, a collective of journal entries from real life soldiers like Sergeant Timothy J. Gaestel mentions in his letter that an improvised explosive device went off causing severe injury on his back. While Timothy stays calm, his untrained partner starts to panic and begins to fear for the worst of the situation:
This guy didn't react well when I showed him my back- he started flipping out and yelling, “Oh G., you got him man, oh he’s hit in the back and is bleeding. As you can imagine, I was pretty pissed off that this point, and I showed my anger toward the people in the town that were driving through.

Show More
Related

  • The Mirror With A Memory Analysis

    417 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the chapter, “The Mirror with a Memory”, the authors, James Davidson and Mark Lytle, describe numerous things that evolved after the civil war, including the life of Jacob Riis, the immigration of new peoples in America, and the evolution of photography. The authors’ purpose in this chapter is to connect the numerous impacts photography had on the past as well as its bringing in today’s age.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Torie Deghett's The War Photo No One Would Publish

    1495 Words  | 3 Pages

    Images can manipulate many scenarios but it’s tactic used to show the realities of our world. Despite what we see, picture taken of the war and events occurring in the war doesn’t mean they aren’t real. We all live in a messy world and history is constantly repeating itself. Pictures are taken to spread awareness and empathy. It is a reason DeGhett argued that the Iraq brunt solider photograph taken by Kenneth Jarecke should have been posted in order for the public to get a sense that the war occurring at the moment is nothing like in the movies. Images are powerful and we must learn to always look closely and

    Read More

  • Review of the Forgotten Soldier

    669 Words  | 2 Pages

    Many people question if Guy Sajer, author of The Forgotten Soldier, is an actual person or only a fictitious character. In fact, Guy Sajer in not a nom de plume. He was born as Guy Monminoux in Paris on 13 January 1927. At the ripe young age of 16, while living in Alsace, he joined the German army. Hoping to conceal his French descent, Guy enlisted under his mother's maiden name-Sajer. After the war Guy returned to France where he became a well known cartoonist, publishing comic books on World War II under the pen name Dimitri.

    Read More

  • War and Memory in Irene Zabytko?s ?Home Soil?, Bruce Weigl?s ?Song of Napalm?, and Wilfred Owen?s ?Dulce et Decorum Est?

    755 Words  | 2 Pages

    Bullets flying through the air right over me, my knees are shaking, and my feet are numb. I see familiar faces all around me dodging the explosives illuminating the air like lightning. Unfortunately, numerous familiar faces seem to disappear into the trenches. I try to run from the noise, but my mind keeps causing me to re-illustrate the painful memories left behind.

    Read More

  • Analysis of Soldier's Home by Ernest Hemingway

    705 Words  | 2 Pages

    The story, A Soldiers Home, is about a man in conflict with the past and present events in his life. The young man’s name is Harold Krebs. He recently returned from World War 1 to find everything almost exactly the same as when he left. He moved back into his parents house, where he found the same car sitting in the same drive way. He also found the girls looking the same, except now they all had short hair. When he returned to his home town in Oklahoma the hysteria of the soldiers coming home was all over. The other soldiers had come home years before Krebs had so everyone was over the excitement. When he first returned home he didn’t want to talk about the war at all. Then, when he suddenly felt the urge and need to talk about it no one wanted to hear about it. When he returned all of the other soldiers had found their place in the community, but Harold needed more time to find his place. In the mean time he plays pool, “practiced on his clarinet, strolled down town, read, and went to bed.”(Hemingway, 186) When his mother pressures him to get out and get a girlfriend and job, he te...

    Read More

  • DO WE NEED WAR PHOTOGRAPHY

    1822 Words  | 4 Pages

    A good example of photographs preserving history is ‘The Auschwitz Album’. Why, because it is the only surviving photographic evidence of the procedure leading murder of Jew’s arriving by train to Auschwitz-Birkenau.

    Read More

  • Contrasting Photos: A Soldier's Home Coming

    631 Words  | 2 Pages

    War has always been inevitable throughout the history of the world. The outcomes can differ greatly; it’s usually either a win or a loss. Wins or losses are just definite statements, but photos can represent these statements. Alfred Eisenstaedt’s “V-J Day in Times Square” shows an American sailor kissing a young woman right in the middle of Times Square, despite their surroundings. This iconic photo was taken after the U.S. declared victory over Japan in World War II, and was published in Life magazine a week later. John Gap’s (III) photo shows a young girl being consoled at a soldier’s funeral in a local high school gymnasium, later to be buried at Arlington National Cemetery. This humble photo was taken during the war still raging in Afghanistan, showing that these types of losses happen quite often, as there are no iconic photos for Afghanistan compared to the photo shot after the win over World War II. Unlike its counterpart, this photo was published only at a local level on a website. Both these photos show a soldier being dismissed to go home from war. Although the two photos share that common factor, the scenario in which the soldier comes home differs greatly. Through these photos, Albert Eisenstaedt and John Gaps III help evoke pathos and give the observer a sense of the pride and the devastation felt of a home coming from war using photographic elements such as framing, focus, and angles.

    Read More

  • Susan Sontag On Photography Essay

    661 Words  | 2 Pages

    I believe that in able to see the world we should photograph life at a certain moment in time so we can capture reality, and able to look back at it. Susan Sontag expresses, “Although there is a sense which the camera does indeed capture reality, not just interpret it, photographs are as much an interpretation of the world as paintings and drawings are” (Sontag 6). Interpreting this quote can go a different way such as, that the photographer is capturing the world by the lenses, not the eyes. I believe that if we’re experiencing the world through the lenses, or rather

    Read More

  • Analysis Of From Realism To Virtual Reality

    1032 Words  | 3 Pages

    When something significant happens, every media outlet wants to be the first to let you hear about it. However, to do so they have to draw you in. This is where the deception comes in. In “From Realism to Virtual Reality” the author argues the difference between realism and actual war like images. He explains that the way war is portrayed by the media is not how it really happens. He finds that journalists publish certain images from a war setting just to evoke emotion, whether is portrays the war as it really is or not. For example, he found that many journalists published stand still photographs of mostly dead bodies during the war just to make the audience believe what was being published. Images like these are not accurate, real representations of the war in its entirety. The media is not looking to publish the truth; they’re looking to publish a good

    Read More

  • Reader-Response on Soldier's Home

    1223 Words  | 3 Pages

    The initial reaction I received from reading Soldier's Home, and my feelings about Soldier's Home now are not the same. Initially, I thought Harold Krebs is this soldier who fought for two years, returns home, and is disconnected from society because he is in a childlike state of mind, while everyone else has grown up. I felt that Krebs lost his immature years, late teens to early 20's, because he went from college to the military. I still see him as disconnected from society, because there isn't anyone or anything that can connect him to the simple life that his once before close friends and family are living. He has been through a traumatic experience for the past two years, and he does not have anyone genuinely interested in him enough to take the time to find out what's going on in his mind and heart. Krebs is in a battle after the battle.

    Read More

  • Narrative Experience In The Stones Cry Out By Hikaru Okuizumi

    766 Words  | 2 Pages

    Collecting evidences, gathering recourses, and providing reliable insights of a historical event are certainly not some easy tasks to perform for an author who has no first-hand experience of such event. Nevertheless, it is even more challenging for authors to re-organize, recount, and represent traumatic war-time memories to a body of audience with no direct experience of the intensely dangerous confrontations, especially belligerent experiences that happened abroad. To convey the anxiety and trauma resulted from extreme violence, moral conflicts and physio-psychological damages without unconsciously marginalizing any particular historical event, authors who write about traumatic experiences must be cautious when they try to visually and mentally

    Read More

  • Analysis Of 'The Soldier' By Rupert Brooke

    1712 Words  | 4 Pages

    The way that Rosenberg chose to present the war through his poem expresses his dislike for the whole effort. Picturing the fact that a simple rat could be seen as an enemy due to it being on both sides of the war in an obvious hyperbole, but this device is used as a way for Rosenberg to express his beliefs that the war has gone too far. Line 7 states “Droll rat, they would shoot you if they knew” (Rosenberg 2030) when referring to how a rat can easily cross between two opposing sides of the war. He expresses how the rat is not a part of the war and a small sense of jealousy towards that rat can be seen through other lines of the poem. As Tomas Staley said when speaking about Rosenberg “as the war became the universe of poetry, the power of

    Read More

  • The Psychological Effects of War Exposed in The Sniper by Liam O’Flaherty

    583 Words  | 2 Pages

    War can destroy a man both in body and mind for the rest of his life. In “The Sniper,” Liam O’Flaherty suggests the horror of war not only by presenting its physical dangers, but also by showing its psychological effects. We are left to wonder which has the longer lasting effect—the visible physical scars or the ones on the inside?

    Read More

  • Examples Of Imagery In A Farewell To Arms

    734 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are many horrific parts of war that are unforgettable when seen in real life. First, Hemingway uses imagery to portray the theme by stating, "I tried to move, but could not move. I heard the machine-guns and rifles firing across the river and all along the river. There was a great splashing and I saw the start shells go up and burst and float whitely and rockets going up and heard the bombs..." (Hemingway 55). The author shows how a soldier gets stuck in the middle of a scary war situation because he did not c a re enough to pay attention to the events taking place outside of the hide out by using imagery. He visually gives the reader an idea of the theme he is portraying. To add to this idea, Hemingway expresses the theme by stating the condition of the soldier after the explosion. He says, "It was Passini and when I touched him he screamed. His legs were toward me and I saw in the dark and the light that they were both smashed above the knee. One leg was gone and the other was held by tendons and part of the trouser and the stump twitched as jerked as though it were connected," (Hemingway 55). In this situation, he shows the reader how the soldier suffers major physical injuries because he was naive about the events taking place in the war zone. They should pay attention to their surroundings. Furthermore, Hemingway portrays his theme using imagery in order to give an idea of the

    Read More

  • Ideology of the Photographs: Thinking with Sontag and Butler

    2852 Words  | 6 Pages

    Since the beginning of civilisation the question can art have the capacity to transform the world politically and morally has invariably haunted the philosophers and social scientists alike. This paper makes an attempt to address two different but interrelated questions in the light of photography by primarily focusing on Abu Ghraib pictures. First, I intend to look critically at Butler’s claim that framing of reality in a certain way imposes constraints on what can be heard, seen and read during the times of war. And second, I propose to consider the various ways in which the relationship between photography and ethical responsiveness can be explored by invoking the idea of face propounded by Levinas in one of his interviews.

    Read More

More about Limitations of Photography in Portraying War Realities

Open Document