Smasher's Rivalry

750 Words2 Pages

In The Secret River; through the perspective of William Thornhill, Kate Grenville explores a convict's life and their experience when they are given the option to die, or be taken from their home in Europe to the foreign Victorian State. The most obvious option is for someone to continue living as opposed to them to die as a criminal. The novel is remarkably unique in which providing the point of view of both the Europeans and the Aboriginals as the conflict between them develops and culminates as a result of their opposing cultures. As this rivalry progresses, William Thornhill and other European settlers are 'trapped' within this conflict, and each are given the opportunity to choose how to escape their entrapment. In the novel, many chose …show more content…

This behaviour is extremely evident in his ill treatment to and towards the Aboriginals. In the scene where William Thornhill is at Smasher's place, William observes Smasher's treatment to a female, Aboriginal that Smasher took ‘captive'. “William saw the whip catch her around the small of the back as she stumbled outside," (pg. 262). This example of cruelty emphasises on Smasher's disgusting treatment towards the Aboriginals. The words such as "stumble [and] the whip catch her" are dehumanising the Aboriginal female in this scene, and making her sound like a dangerous animal that needs and deserves to be whipped for wrongdoing. Together the words "stumble” and “whip”, demean the rights of the Aboriginal woman and as a result, this use of dehumanisation highlights Smasher's treatment towards the Aboriginals, and subtly gives the audience the image of Europeans in general, as a race that treated the Native Australians as if they had no …show more content…

Throughout the story’s progression, Blackwood secretively becomes involved in a friendship and agreement with the Aboriginals who migrated to stay nearby ‘his’ home. Blackwood explains how they came to the agreement: “They come down, see… tell me to bugger off… [They] had their bloody spears up ready…give them some victuals. But they wasn’t having none… they let me stay. Made it real clear- stay on the beach,” (pg.215). Soon after Blackwood explains his confrontation with the Aboriginals, a voice called out from the lagoon. “[It was an Aboriginal woman, and] Blackwood was speaking in her own tongue. [Blackwood’s] words were slow and clumsy, but Thornhill could see the woman listening and understanding… I find them quiet and peaceable folk, Blackwood said,” (pp.216-7). This acceptance and hospitable relationship between Blackwood and the Aboriginals, shows the audience that Blackwood made the decision to make a comfortable relationship with the land owners. It is evident that Blackwood has changed his perspective on the Aboriginals through the contradiction of his confrontation, in which he uses words such as “bloody [and] bugger” to show that he did not feel welcome near or around them; and his agreement and “understanding” friendship in which words such as “peaceable” are used to show that they have a quiet, enjoyable relationship. This contradiction shows that Blackwood came to change his

More about Smasher's Rivalry

Open Document