Shipping News and the Great Gatsby: An Analysis

453 Words1 Page

When a group of rowdy guys get together nothing good ever seems to come of it, and when alcohol is added something terrible is bound to happen. Nutbeem's party seems to be no exception to this. I can picture this party scene happening today in an almost similar way. It is quite rare to have a party that consists of solely men, but for the purpose of saying goodbye to a friend it makes perfect sense. And yet the party is still very realistic in how it changes courses once alcohol is involved. Overall this chapter made me feel sorry for Nutbeem and his destroyed boat. He was so excited to finally be heading off to sea again that he threw a farewell party and invited all his friends, only to have them destroy his most prized possession. Quoyle even says, "There was a mood of rough excitement that had more in common, he thought, with a parking-lot fight behind a waterfront bar than a jolly good-bye to Nutbeem." It seems that the crowd of men had come to enjoy free beer and excitement rather than to say goodbye to Nutbeem. Its sad to think that maybe they did not destroy his boat to keep him in Newfoundland, but only as a way to cause some commotion. However, one thing this chapter did not need to tell the story of Nutbeem's party was the "Hairy Devil" story that Tert Card told Quoyle. It seemed to have no relevance to what was going on in the chapter and only took away from the main idea of the party. The only possible benefit from Tert Card's story was for it to show how drunk he and everyone else had become at the party. In reading the excerpt from Cannery Row by John Steinbeck I noticed that in many ways it was similar to "The Hairy Devil" chapter in The Shipping News. "And it is also generally understood that a party hardly ever goes the way it is planned or intended." This excerpt from Cannery Row helps illustrate the main themes of both works. In both stories the parties were not intended to get out of control but they took a sudden change of events, mostly due to the consumption of alcohol. The characters in Cannery Row seem almost happy and excited when a fight breaks out at the party.

Open Document