Rhetorical Analysis Of Emily Shire

1026 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essay on the history of halloween

Rhetorical Analysis of Emily Shire “Is It Now Slutoween for 7-Year-Olds? Really?”
In “Is It Now Slutoween for 7-Year-Olds? Really?” Emily Shire addresses the question of whether or not to wear gender-prescription Halloween costume for girls. Published on September 29, 2015, this is one of the many articles that Shire has contributed to thedailybeast.com, most of which covers popular culture, women’s issues, health and sex and date. There appear to be no Kairos event. However, Shire against little girl to wear costumes that are provocative. The target audiences of thedailybeast.com is women. Shire is a reporter and cheat sheeter for The Daily Beast. Her work has appeared in The Week, The Atlantic, Salon, Slate, and The Forward. She is a writer …show more content…

According to Shire women are brouhaha over Halloween costumes for two reasons, she then explains the two camps are: a) slut-shaming women enjoy wearing risqué costumes and reveling in a flamboyant display of sexiness one night a year b) by exploring the pressure on women to de-robe and conform to some nautical/law enforcement authority/janitorial variation on the sex kitten fantasy. Shire mentioned Lin Kramer wrote her letter that on Party City’s website boys costumes that are related to professions are more than girls. She also point out that she recalled she wore many feminine costumes during her childhood and grow up to be an independent-minded feminist. Shire acknowledges that according to Dr. Michael the influence of Halloween costumes could add up. However, Shire shifts to talk about how girls costumes looks nothing like an actual occupation while boy’s costume do. She also claims the costumes were looser twenty years ago. Shire concludes the great joys of Halloween are to dress up and costume stores should offer full-range of options to explore for both …show more content…

The source is “Dr. Michael Brody, a child psychiatrist and chair of the media committee for the american academy of child psychiatry told the daily beast that halloween costumes is like role-playing and it effect the way kids grow up.” citing this source boosts shire’s credibility by showing that she has provided expert opinions to support her claim. She also reference to her own personal experience of what she dress up when she were young and how she became a independent-minded feminist because of that to introduce and support the issue, which shows that she has a personal
Adding to her ethos appeals, shire uses facts ,she points out that in Kramra included in her letter that in the “classic costumes sections for toddlers on Party City’s website around 30 percent of the costumes for boys are related to professions while just under 7 percent are in the girls’ sections.These facts are a logically support of her claim that halloween has somehow become a lightning rod for gender politics. The details and the numbers build an appeal to logos and impress upon the reader that this is a problem should be discuss and

Show More
Related

  • Lianne George Why Are We Dressing Our Daughters Like This Analysis

    488 Words  | 1 Pages

    George starts with the example of the Christian schoolgirl outfit, once meant to represent sexual purity and chastity, it now has been fetishized to the point where it represents sexuality bursting at the seams. She states that it does not help that older women are now wearing promiscuous outfits adorned with childlike slogans and logos. The increasingly scantily clad nature of grown women acting as role models for children causes them to dress like their role models. That is, in a provocative manner. George says that such clothing blurs the line

    Read More

  • Article Critique of Deborah Tannen's "Marked Women"

    840 Words  | 2 Pages

    The author explains that men have the freedom to wear what they want without much meaning being read from their clothes, but for a woman every style has a meaning. In the article Deborah Tannen says “There is no woman's hair style that can be called standard, that says nothing about her” further supporting her point. The author uses the different clothing styles of three ladies in her conference meeting as examples when she tries to attribute them? to their respective personalities. However, she noticed that the men were all dressed alike because they had the freedom to. In my opinion, the author’s evaluation is restricted. Tannen did not consider the formal setting of her case study so to say.In such settings, men are often restricted to corporate outfits and a plain haircut just like the ones she observed in her male colleagues in the article (page #) . For instance, it is inappropriate for a man to go job hunting or for an interview in a pair of shorts and plain T shirt, but in a casual place like a bar he has more freedom in his choice of outfits. This example shows that men are only unmarked in certain situations and settings.

    Read More

  • Book Review: Cinderella Ate My Daughter: Dispatches From the Front Lines of the New Girlie-Girl Culture Adriana Cerezo

    715 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this book, Peggy Orenstein explores the land of pink. She takes us on an adventurous trip to try and find out the truth about what society tells our young girls what they should be wearing, how they should be acting and most importantly looks are what matters. Orenstein herself is a mother of a preschool aged daughter so the topic of what influences young girls is of great importance to her. She struggles with making the correct decisions for her own daughter, Daisy, as she dives into the girlie-girl world, because as even she has found out, it is impossible to steer clear of it. She talks with historians, marketers, psychologists, neuroscientists, parents, and children themselves. She returns to the original fairy tales, seeks out girls’ virtual presence online, and ponders the meaning of child beauty pageants. In the process, she faces down her own confusion as a mother and woman about issues of how to raise a girl and teach her about her own femininity.

    Read More

  • How Do Gender Roles Get Portrayed in Disney Films?

    704 Words  | 2 Pages

    England, Dawn, Lara Descartes, and Melissa Collier-Meek. "Gender Roll Portrayal and the Disney Princesses." N.p., 10 Feb. 2011. Web.

    Read More

  • The Prism Of Gender, By Catherine G. Valentine

    2064 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Disney store for example, mainly focuses on costume, nonetheless, all of the boy toys in there seemed to portray the concepts of strength, speed and power. For example, the Spider Man, Hulk and Captain America costumes all had an excessive amount of padding in the upper body. It was the extra padding that reinforced the concepts of strength and power that surround men. In addition, the toys involved shields and swords, which encouraged competitions, power and strength, all which have to do with the way men are perceived. Girls on the other hand, all of the costumes available were in reference to princesses. The article, The Pink Dragon Is Female by Adie Nelson examines the extent to which children’s costumes reproduced or follow feminine or masculine norms. The way the Disney costumes are presented, serves as evidence for Nelsons findings, which suggest the feminine costumes were associated with beauty and animals, while the masculine costumes emphasized the warrior theme of masculinity (249). It is these types of messages that contribute to the way boys and girls get

    Read More

  • Ms. Suzy Weiss's Analysis

    261 Words  | 1 Pages

    Ms. Suzy Weiss discusses in her essay the arguments between if wearing a costume created from an idea around human aspects will be racists. University of Michigan school is showing students the proper way to dress for Halloween; the only “right” way to dress would be a desalinated zombie. Suzy is arguing that this is too sensitive and students will not be upset if they see a girl in a hula skirt if she is not from Hawaii. If these rules are given as a tool she believes that a whole background of tradition is needed. Halloween is for different stereotypes, people use different ethnic costumes because it's the one day a year you can dress out of your comfort zone, it's not for slamming a different culture.

    Read More

  • Catcher In The Rye Rhetorical Analysis

    444 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger is an excellent novel and was written to absolute perfection with the use of rhetorical devices and literary elements. The novel itself is all about how a young teenager who narrates the events of his life get him into a mental hospital, he tries to seek advice from his old high school professors who in turn give him the same advice which has not been helpful. His point of view of the world is highly unique and philosophical which he constantly states that this world is full of phonies. Holden is incredibly talented and extremely intelligent, but his view of the world is so unorthodox it makes the rest of us have a different perspective on life and of the world we live in (Bryan 1065).

    Read More

  • Evelia Rhetorical Analysis

    337 Words  | 1 Pages

    Evelia was expected to be overcome with emotions on the day of her Quinceañera. Evelias father was disappointed that his music did not bring her to tears. The meaning of the Quinceañera ceremony has changed drastically between Evelia and her parent’s generation. Her parents and family expect specific gender norms to be incorporated within the ceremony, but Evelia does not have the same ideals. She is expected to be overcome with emotion and completely fixated on marriage and beauty, but Evelia has different expectations for her life.

    Read More

  • The History Of Cosplay

    806 Words  | 2 Pages

    56). Despite the origin of the word cosplay, cosplay is largely thought of as directly inspired by Japanese popular culture (Okabe, 2012). Many of the conventions that these cosplayers attend, also known as ‘Cons’ for short, began popping up in many cities in the United States in the 1990s (Pollak, 2006). Currently, conventions are held in around 30 states in the United States (Leng, 2013, p.90). As popularity for these conventions grow, more and more people have started to participate in the act of cosplay (Leng, 2013, p.90). With the emergence of cosplay trends such as gender-bending, cross-playing, and mashups it is interesting to look into how traditional expressions of gender roles and identity are undermined in the cosplay community. In this paper, I plan to investigate the relationship between gender roles, gender identity and gender expression through participation in

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of The Speech Of Miss Polly Baker

    901 Words  | 2 Pages

    In, “The Speech of Miss Polly Baker” written by Benjamin Franklin (one of the Founding Fathers) in 1747, brought up the disparities that were between men and women within the judicial system. Also, “The Speech of Miss Polly Baker” also briefly points out, how religion has been intertwined with politics. All throughout “The Speech of Miss Polly Baker,” Benjamin Franklin uses very intense diction and syntax to help support what he is trying to express to the rest of society. Also writing this speech in the view point of a women, greatly helps establish what he is trying to say. If Benjamin Franklin was to write it as a man, the speech my have not had the same passionate effect as it currently has.

    Read More

  • The Destruction Of Gender Roles In The 1970's

    689 Words  | 2 Pages

    Gender roles have always been present in society, especially when it comes to women. Traditionally, women were expected to stay at home to clean, cook, and care for the children while men were expected to play the role of breadwinner. Though women in the 1970’s attempted to branch off from the norm, television media forced the illusion of a continued anticipated gender role society by portraying women in the old fashioned housewife role. An issue arose with media powers when someone had something to say. In 1981, Legos made a controversial statement when they released the ad of a young girl in overalls playing with Legos. In this time period, girls were expected to wear pink and play with dolls; boys played with Legos. Legos moved a nation by deceiving the expected roles of men and women.

    Read More

  • Stereotypes In Picture Books

    1473 Words  | 3 Pages

    There has been a lot of quarrels over the years about how children’s picture books are embracing traditions and presenting gender stereotypes. In an article I found, author Narahara May of “Gender Stereotypes in Children’s Picture Books,” discusses two major problems. One being that gender stereotypes and sexism has an emotional impact on the development of children’s identity and development. Secondly, she explains about how books in the last decade have portrayed gender negatively. Furthermore, I will be discussing May’s ideas further in depth by examining the portrayals of gender stereotypes found in the popular “Berenstain Bears” picture books. Although there are picture books now out there that are challenging gender stereotypes, to my

    Read More

  • Essay On Gender Stereotypes In Children

    537 Words  | 2 Pages

    Adolescent is essential in understanding gender development. With a society that classifies everything in feminine or masculine. Children are identifying by colors and toys. Girl’s wear pink, play with dolls and have pretend kitchen while, boys wear blue, play with action figures and have pretend guns. These differences are still instilled in young children what is socially acceptable. Some stores have tried to combat the gender stereotype by eliminating toys aisle and instead use a genderless aisle. The removal of gender label removes gender stereotypes. However, gender differences are also evidences in marketing advertised. Stores like Walmart and Toys R US recently, tried to tone down their gender specific children’s marketing. Toys can be representative as way children should be gender identities. For example, females should play with dolls. However, playing with dolls does not naturally portray person as feminine or it proves a girl as female. By

    Read More

  • Amy Tan Two Kinds Rhetorical Analysis

    378 Words  | 1 Pages

    In Amy Tan’s story “Two Kinds,” lack of mutual understanding of feelings creates a strain on this mother-daughter relationship, preventing Jing Mei from seeing the true value of her mother’s sacrifices until it’s too late.

    Read More

  • Media and Mass Communication

    885 Words  | 2 Pages

    Exploring the first text type which is targeted to little girls, is easy to quickly notice the use of women ‘‘roles’’ and stereotypes throughout the video, because in this case the producers do it in a very explicit way. They show a little girl who is very happy with all the thi...

    Read More

More about Rhetorical Analysis Of Emily Shire

Open Document