Review Of Fitzgerald's Gatsby: The World As Ash Heap '

673 Words2 Pages

In his essay entitled “Fitzgerald’s Gatsby: The World as Ash Heap”, James E. Miller proposes that Gatsby was a “victim of his American heritage […,] a victim whose innocence transcended his corruption” (Miller). By suggesting that Gatsby was a victim of the “American Dream” and that his innocence justified and annulled his corruption, Miller paints the picture of a Gatsby without agency in a world that doomed Gatsby to his inevitable downfall. And while there is some suggestion to this Gatsby, such as the nature of Gatsby’s story in which “it is only Nick’s Gatsby that we come to know” proposing that Gatsby is incapable of telling his own story, there, too, are contradictions to this portrayal (Miller). Deeming someone as a victim, according …show more content…

No one controlled Gatsby into creating this dream; he created it himself. In fact, Gatsby’s dream seems to start with Daisy – from the moment Gatsby saw Daisy’s residence, “he committed himself to the following of a grail” (130). The extravagance of her house – the …show more content…

The American dream is “the ideal that every [one…] should have an equal opportunity to achieve success and prosperity through hard work, determination, and initiative”; however, Gatsby goes beyond this dream. Because Gatsby achieves the American Dream and yet he still desires more, Gatsby is not “innocent” – he has created an appetite that he cannot sustain. In a way, he corrupts this dream, as he corrupts those around him. Miller states that “Gatsby was as much the victim of his American heritage as he was of Tom, Daisy, and George Wilson” (Miller). In reality, Gatsby is the one that victimizes the aforementioned characters as well as Nick; Gatsby constantly manipulates the people around him. As aforesaid, Gatsby pressures Daisy into saying she “never loved [Tom]”; Gatsby keeps repeating the phrase “you never loved him” until Daisy is forced to say it back (117). Above this, Gatsby manipulates Tom’s and Daisy’s life, so everything he does is a strategic move to get Daisy’s love. Gatsby even manipulates Nick so he can stage his and Daisy’s meeting because he “wants to see her right next door” and does not “want to do anything out of the way” (77). Even Jordan can see that the only reason Gatsby befriended Nick is so that he could stage a casual meeting with Daisy.

Open Document