Representation of New York in Manhattan and Sex and the City

713 Words2 Pages

Representation of New York in Manhattan and Sex and the City

Manhattan, the city of New York, is often depicted in the media by

images of skyscraper buildings and yellow taxis. I am going to analyse

the representation of New York by looking at and comparing the opening

sequences of the series "Sex and the City" with the film "Manhattan".

I will be looking specifically at how the directors achieve their

interpretations of New York by the images of New York and the

cinematic devices that they use. Both directors have a similar idea of

portraying New York as a city of two halves but they both have very

different ways of doing this.

John Thomas, director of "Sex and the City", uses a range of cinematic

devices including camera shots, pace, editing and some images and

stereotypes to show Carrie as a metaphor for New York. In the first

few frames of the clip Carrie is in a close up shot with the

background around her blurred and not in focus. The focus here is on

Carrie's emotions; she is confident, relaxed and happy which

represents the bold vibrant and colourful side to New York. The clip

is divided into two halves, separated by a shot in the middle of

steering through the centre of a traffic jam from a low angle looking

up. Although this is quite an ambiguous shot and could also represent

New York as looking down on Carrie as being mysterious and

intimidating showing the other side to New York itself, to me it shows

a journey back to reality from the stereotypical side of New York

representing a change or a definitive border between the two halves of

New York. Towards the end of the clip tension is built up by the music

to a clim...

... middle of paper ...

...rall impression that is expressed to the audience

shows the reality of New York.

I conclude that although "Manhattan" and "Sex and the City" were

filmed in completely different decades and in completely different

styles they still have a lot in common about the way that they portray

New York City. Both directors are portraying the suburban reality and

the stereotypical romance as two very different sides of New York. The

fact that the directors show these sides of New York in a different

order suggests that they are giving hindmost impressions last. "Sex

and the City" concludes in reality with Carrie being splashed but

everybody carries on regularly with their busy everyday lives. However

"Manhattan's" ultimate image is of fireworks over the New York skyline

suggesting the romantic and stereotypical view of New York.

Open Document