Introduction
Reform movements in public policy are utilized to address shortcomings or make a change in certain aspects of society. One such reform was in the form of a bill passed by the Massachusetts legislature in 1970 to address shortcomings of Massachusetts police officers (Morreale, 2013). The legislature passed the Quinn Bill Establishing The Police Career Incentive Pay Program which paid Massachusetts police officers for earning college degrees (Paynich, 2009). This incentive program became commonly known as the Quinn Bill and was in effect where nearly 40 years before being gutted in 2009 because of public scrutiny and current economic crisis.
Quinn Bill
A number of Supreme Court rulings in the 1960s highlighted the need to change
…show more content…
The timing of eliminating the Quinn Bill is most certainly due to the 2008 financial crisis as lawmakers search for ways to reduce spending. Unfortunately, the lack of funding at the state level placed an enormous burden on some towns and communities throughout the state to fund Quinn Bill benefits guaranteed in some union contracts. In 2012, the Massachusetts Supreme Court ruled that communities do not automatically have to fund the state’s share of the cost of the Quinn Bill and the Legislature stopped paying any money for the education benefit (Fernandes, 2012). The high court’s ruling frees communities from paying the state's portion of the Quinn Bill unless these funds are guaranteed by collective bargaining agreements. However, some communities have chosen to continue the education benefits to police officers despite the lack of funding from the state because they see value in an educated police force. It is doubtful that the financing or the purpose of the Quinn Bill would have ever come into question without the economic hardships and downturn that started in …show more content…
Michael Widmer, the president of the Massachusetts Taxpayer Foundation, feels that the Quinn Bill is an “outdated benefit” and he feels that “it should be a basic requirement for a police officer” to have a bachelor degree (Fernandes, 2012, p. A1). However, the primary stakeholders surrounding the Quinn Bill are the legislators that passed the bill and continued to fund the incentive until it was eliminated in 2009. Apparently, the legislator's position has changed due to the financial pressure of the economic crisis of 2008. The governing boards of each community that supported the pay incentive also had to equally match funds from the state and are responsible for payment to the police officers eligible for the incentive. Each community’s position has dramatically changed with the loss of state funding. Each community that relied on state funds now must decide how to pay the incentive to their police officers or dissolve the program altogether. The colleges and universities are also key stakeholders in the Quinn Bill as criminal justice, and law degrees became big business for these learning institutions; more degrees handed out meant more money generated. During the life of the Quinn Bill, higher education institutions came under fire for their curriculum and teaching practices and were once referred to as diploma mills (Fernandes, 2012). Of
Quinn gains a unique perspective on humanity through the main character of the novel, Ishmael. Ishmael is a gorilla. And Ishmael is a teacher who communicates with humans telepathically. On the surface, this hardly seems to be a character who would appear in a serious book; more likely a children's story, a fable, or perhaps a bad science fiction novel. Yet Ishmael is none of these, and Ishmael is a strong character, with a powerful intellect and a serious purpose. The character of Ishmael needs to be non-human in order to be effective. Looking in on civilization from the outside gives him a perspective from which to criticize humanity without hypocrisy. To hear the oppressor repent is not nearly so effective as to hear the voice of the oppressed demand freedom and restitution.
During the seventies in New Jersey created a program that could change life in society. This program occurred only in twenty-eight cities. Government and public officials were excited about this concept. Police officials were not so much. Foot patrol made officers walk in sleet and snow. Assigned foot patrol was a way of punishment for officers. State funding of foot patrol shut the mouths of some people. Silence stopped after the “Police Foundation”(Kelling) put foot patrol to the actual test. To contrary belief this rattled some arguments in the community an...
In the early 1900’s the Boston police were ranked among the best law enforcement groups in the world. Underneath this reputation of being one of the best in the world, the police department was having some trouble. Most of the police stations were old and deteriorating. An officer would have to many hours a week. The pay for most policemen were very low. While inflation was in much affect the policeman’s salary stayed the same. And the men were promised raises but never saw much more than they had already made. The Boston city policemen were very angry over these iss...
Lockwood, Andrew. School Finance Reform in Michigan Proposal A: Retrospective. Lansing: Michigan Department of Treasury, 2002.
Policing in the United States has mainly been based and expanded on the ideas of English way of policing. The English way of policing has not only been used as the basis for American policing but it has also been used to commence an era of evolving police agencies. In its early years, policing in the United States was largely regarded as a civic duty or responsibility of community members. The appointed officers were neither trained nor paid for their services to community members. Consequently, the chosen Sheriffs were usually motivated by financial incentives and lost their focus on enforcement of the law, which contributed to the perception that policing was primarily reactive in nature. However, the nature and structure of policing changed significantly following the emergence of urbanization, industrialism, and the society, which resulted in increase in crime. This forced the police or law enforcement officers to adopt a more proactive approach rather than the reactive approach that was traditionally associated with law enforcement. Notably, the history of policing has been characterized by considerable changes from time to time due to several factors like technological advancements and increase in threats to security.
Quinney subscribed in part to Marxist ideology (Mutchnick et al., 1990). Quinney’s views on criminality and social inequality are rooted in the belief that class conflict creates an environment favoring those with greater means of accumulation over those with lesser means of accumulation. The resultant interpretation by Quinney followers is greater means to wealth equates to lesser involvement in criminal activities. This thought is well told in Quinney’s works on white-collar crime. It is the writer’s assertion that minority communities seem largely superficially impacted by white-collar crime as a means of exploitation upon them, rather than originating within them. Ruddell and Thomas (2010) state policing agencies within in areas with larger populations of minorities employ more law enforcement officers and spend more of their annual budgets on enforcement activities. This is largely a representative of Quinney’s theoretical examination on social conflicts using Marxist theory to explain how social structural impacts on crime leads to the eventuality of developing systemic support by way of law and policy used to oppress the poor to keep class divisions structurally intact (Mutchnick et al., 1990). The law serves to benefit the interests of one group over another. Policing’s role as an instrument of the system, is
The Street Terrorism Enforcement and Prevention Act, also known as the STEP Act has been challenged with criticism. During the 1980s California’s high level of gang activity created concern in the local communities. Due to the high concern legislations began being written. The STEP Act, although concerned with a reduction in gang crimes began perceived by many as applied disproportionately against minorities.
This reform idea was first introduced by New York Governor Andrew Cuomo. As an argument for his claim, Woodman shares statistics that show that having a college degree over a high school degree increases a person’s chances of getting hired by 50%. He asserts that if college education were offered to prison inmates, they would gain an edge in the job market, especially since top colleges and universities are not producing graduates for in-demand fields. “[T]hey’re not going to care that your degree is from University of Sing Sing, not University of Phoenix,” he states in relation to North Dakota’s need for engineers. Offering more job opportunities to ex-convicts would give them what Woodman calls an anchor in
Carey, Kevin. "The In-State Tuition Break, Slowly Disappearing." The New York Times 18 May 2015: A3. Print.
Police reform should start by giving proper training to the new recruits and veterans in the force. During their training, “Law enforcement agencies should adopt and enforce policies prohibiting discrimination based on race, ethnicity immigration status, etc.” (Cops, p.90). It is apparent
Reformers wanted to stray away from political influences and believed that policing should be in the control of police executives (Peak, 2015). While the Political era’s goal was social services, the Reform Era began to shift policing to controlling crime. In addition, the police organizations were reorganized through the study of scientific theory of administration advocated by Fredrick Taylor, which led to the development of maximizing police efficiency (Peak, 2015). To improve professionalism within police departments, O.W. Wilson began emulating what J. Edgar Hoover did with the FBI. In 1924, the FBI director began to raise eligibility standards to develop an incorruptible force. As a result, it had a direct influence on local police agencies by placing emphasis on education, training, honesty and professionalism. Professionalism in police departments came about in the form of new Technological advances and a focus on crime fighting. During this period there were three major advances in technology: two-way radio, police cars and the telephone. Unlike the problems faced during the political era, the advent of these technologies changed everything. With two-way radios, supervisors now had the capability to notify patrol officers of calls and maintain accountability. Patrol cars allowed for greater mobility, which led to officers responding to calls more efficiently. Then telephones allowed for citizens to have a direct line to the police and were encouraged to call for any problem. However, while the advances in technology greatly increased police efficiency, it had unexpected consequences. In contrast, during the political era, officers patrolled on foot, which allowed them to engage citizens and develop a relationship within the community. With the use of police cars, officers no
American policing originated from early English law and is profoundly influenced by its history. Early law enforcement in England took on two forms of policing, one of which heavily influenced modern policing and it is known as the watch (Potter, 2013). The watch consisted, at first, of volunteers which had to patrol the streets for any kind of disorder including crime and fire. After men attempted to get out of volunteering by paying others, it became a paid professional position (Walker & Katz, 2012). The three eras of policing in America are shaped by these early ideas and practices of law enforcement. Throughout time, sufficient improvements and advancements have been made from the political era to the professional era and finally the community era which attempts to eliminate corruption, hire qualified officers and create an overall effective law enforcement system.
A strength is that it would have a change in american policy and having safe environment. Police have “The length of training they receive must drastically increase” is what could work to improve the safety of many different lives. ( “To help the police…,”13). This could work by having an increase of training time, which in return maturity hits the department. Next, Not all states will have the same requirements of the training program. A study was proven that police don’t need high of an education.“Additional research shows that there is little to no requirements of continued education for police officer.”(“To help the police…”,13) On the other hand it’s important because it would influence brief people to joining the police force. As a result, it helps cut down on innocent people being hot in the most obvious way possible. This is what can makes more safier decapitated kind of people. This strong strength is more efficient way of being a cop, showing to the public. Overall, The number of hours increased in the department could led to a more easier
There are some books that you can just sit back and enjoy, just let the authors words wash over you and, most importantly, you don't have to think. And then there's Daniel Quinn's Ishmael.
I have always taken an interest in Criminal Justice and crime prevention ever since middle school and I set out to make my career goal to become a Criminal Justice professional. Thus, pursuing a Criminal Justice master’s degree has been a part of my plans for the future and will become one of my core focuses that I will set up in my graduate studies. It will also enable me to become a more competent working professional and encourage me to advance towards the doctoral program.