In his book Punished by Rewards: the trouble with Gold Stars, Incentive Plans, A’s, Praise, and other Bribes, Alfie Kohn confronts conventional “carrot-and-stick” psychology motivational efforts. This book is an in-depth criticism of motivational psychology that is often practiced at the home, in schools and the office. Kohn’s states that the "Do this and you'll get that," (Kohn, 1993, p. 3) is the sum total prevailing strategy for teachers addressing students, parents training their children, and managers trying to raise office morale. Kohn argues that parents, teachers, and managers suspend “goodies” like movie time, sales commissions and pretty stickers in a similar way that a pet owner would “bribe” a dog into submission. Kohn discredits …show more content…
In Chapter 1, He maps out the traditional behaviorist philosophy as well as pop behaviorism and its notable presence in today’s Western society and why this so (Kohn credits orthodox economic theory and pragmatist belief systems). Chapter 2 refutes known arguments of moral or logical obligation to reward and that it is a naturally intrinsic desire to reward a person. From Kohn’s perspective, the issue does not lie with compensation, but with the use of monetary funds as a reward (offering more money for whatever the case might be). According to Kohn, there are five issues with rewards and the work place: rewards punish, rupture relationships, they ignore reasons, discourage risk-taking, and rewards undermine interest. Kohn argues that the closer the amount of money received is linked to achievement, the more damaging the reward is. Chapter 3 is primarily focused on practical consequences and also summarizes researched evidence supporting the idea that rewards do not translate to enhanced performance of lasting behavioral changes; often these rewards agitate the existing negative behavior. Kohn gives the reader a five-pronged rationale as to why rewards fail in chapters 4 and 5. In chapter 6 Kohn scrutinizes verbal praise, a reward most Americans would not consider negative or damaging. Kohn emphasis that a person must be careful and consider how a person should praise a person, why a person praise should praise a person, and be aware of the effect the praise ha son the person receiving the
The Punishment Imperative, a book based on the transition from a time when punishment was thought to be necessarily harsh to a time where reform in the prion system is needed, explains the reasons why the grand social experiment of severe punishment did not work. The authors of the book, Todd R. Clear and Natasha A. Frost, strongly argue that the previous mindset of harsh punishment has been replaced due to political shifts, firsthand evidence, and spending issues within the government. Clear and Frost successfully assert their argument throughout the book using quantitative and qualitative information spanning from government policies to the reintegration of previous convicts into society.
Punishment has been around for ages. From century to century the thoughts of punishment have changed for good and bad, but the focus of punishment has not changed. With two sides to the story one being to reform or rehabilitate and the other to be punitive and ask for a penalty in return for the wrong doing done. It is hard not to see that there is plenty of controversy revolving around the subject, punishment has with stood the test of time and with good reason. Some would say the need for punishment is obvious, but others believe it has been taken too far. I say, the glue that holds society in order is punishment. Without our government’s systematic penal code to enforce the social norms that are set in place, our neighborhoods might not be as safe. The issue with this type of mentality though, is deciding how far is too far, and how to judge properly.
The exhortation of using incentives to receive and analyze responses reoccurs throughout the book periodically. Levitt and Dubner believe that incentives can be categorized into three different types: moral incentives, social incentives, and economic incentives. Moral incentives are defined as circumstances in which someone acts purely out of conscience or guilt. Social incentives are observed when a person’s actions are solely linked with shame or glory. Economic incentives are when people act with financial interests and benefits in mind. One example portrayed in the book is the day care center in Israel. When parents start getting charged a late fee for picking up their child at the daycare facility, more parents show up late. Before the fine was placed, parents would pick up their kids on time with a moral or social incentive. After the fine was placed parents acted with an economic incentive, which wasn’t as bad as a sense of guilt. Further data shows evidence of relations between incentives and cheating in the Chicago Public School System. In 1996, the school system started to give bonuses based on the standardized test scores of teachers’ students. If a teacher’s students showed improvements on their test scores, the teacher received a monetary bonus. Researchers found after studying score results from 1993–2000 that a spike in cheating occurred in 1996. A three-year study showed that on average cheating occurred in at least 200 Chicago classrooms per year. Therefore, Levitt and Dubner’s theory of incentives is
Overall, the score of the article is a 95 out of a 100 because the author, Carol Patton was able to lure me into reading her entire piece. Additionally, after reading the article, I felt that I gained a bit of knowledge on the importance of reward programs and how it should be a “must have” in the work environment.
Victor Rios is a previous gang member, whom “was given the opportunity” to get out of the youth control complex. In his book “Punished”, he analyzes the experiences of young black and Latino boys in Oakland, California. Rios gives us an intimate description of some of the everyday forms of “hyper discrimination” these minority boys experience. This book review will focus on the main concepts explained in chapters one through three from the book Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys.
In his novel Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys, Dr. Victor M. Rios aims to demonstrate the catastrophe of criminalization, the flops of using cruel and humiliating punishments that attempt to “‘correct’ and ‘manage’ marginalized youths” (p. 23), and to display the consequences that these practices will have on the paths that teenagers take. He does this by documenting parts of his experience in observing forty boys of Black and/or Latino who are “heavily affected by criminal justice policies and practice” (p. 8). Then, he clarifies how these flaws impacted the boys in these situations. The aim of this essay is to summarize Dr. Rios’ observations and analyze and critique the primary arguments made in the book.
Davis discusses the history of the justice system and how the Penitentiary replaced capitol and corporal punishment. She defines Penitentiary as “Imprisonment was regarded as rehabilitative and the penitentiary prison was devised to provide convicts with the conditions for reflecting on their crimes and, through penitence, for reshaping their habits even their souls.3” though the idea of the penitentiary is arguable a new idea during the American Revolution. The penitentiary process was so that prisoners could learn from what they have done by a process of separation and rehabilitation. After slavery and during the early 20th century the level of crime rates rose during the early 1920’s to 1940’s. In the Article Less crime more punishment Adler4,
The use of incentives are debatable whether or not they should be used or not, however it is proven that in some cases it does work. With teenagers if a teacher says that we will get a grade boost by donating money, or time it it PROVEN (word choice) that we will feel more obligated to participate knowing that it will in some way benefit us. As much as we are being selfish and only thinking about how the outcome will benefit us, we still are committing a good deed. And should’t it just be about what the outcome is rather what gets you to the outcome. In the long run, you still end up helping and being kind even though you are doing it only because of the incentive. An incentive is defined as a th...
The Inferno is one of a three part series known as The Divine Comedy, an epic poem written by Dante Alighieri in 1320, a year before his death in 1321. The Inferno tells of the character Dante, and his journey through the nine circles of Hell, with the assistance of the Roman poet Virgil. Each circle of Hell houses different sinners, each being placed according to the severity of their sin. Each punishment in the different pouches of this circle is symbolic in its own way, for instance, fortune tellers walk aimlessly for eternity with their heads twisted around, since they tried to see the future in an unholy manner, they must look back, symbolically into the past not being able to see what’s ahead, for all eternity. Along with normal souls,
In this paper, I will argue that Nietzsche’s view on punishment morally is skewed simply because I believe that a healthy moral individual would not be at rest while another human is being tortured. However, to a certain extent and in some specific situations, many would disagree with me. As for Foucault’s speculation on morality I will agree to certain extent as well.
teach new skills and decrease challenging behaviors” (pg. 24). Based on my own observation, I’ve seen teachers implement a token economy (e.g., happy faces, stars, and stickers of different forms) to shape and reinforce positive behavior in the classroom. To maintain instructional control, tokens would be delivered immediately to a student when following simple instructions (e.g., following circle time, cleaning
In Punished: policing the lives of black and Latino boys author Rios, victor. Victor Rios grew up in the ghetto in the Oakland, California in the 1980s. Rios, a former gang member and juvenile delinquency. Rios managed to escape this trend of gang violent as a teen; he managed to escape the gang violent lifestyle from his peers. He provides us a with a depth overview of a three-year study of 40 minority youths, 30 of whom were previously arrested. The study was done in Oakland, California. Rios give us a clear overview inner city young Latino and African American. Rios emphasize on the difficult lives of these young men, who are faced with policies in their schools, communities, and policing. Importantly, he gives us a clear understanding
Dante Alighieri, a medieval Italian poet who worked in the vernacular was famously known for his writing of “The Divine Comedy. The Divine Comedy which was originally named The Comedy is a series of three books which documented the Christian soul’s journey after life, from hell, to purgatory, and ultimately salvation. Dante himself is the main character and is led by a Roman poet, Virgil, who promised to lead him “Forth to an eternal place” (Pearson 215). In the first book “The Inferno”, Virgil led Dante into the gates of Hell.
Henderlong, Jennifer, and Mark R. Lepper. "The Effects of Praise on Children's Intrinsic Motivation: A Review and Synthesis." Psychological Bulletin 128.5 (2002): 774-95. Web. 28 Feb. 2011.
The reward system is a beneficial behavioral modification teaching method, which promotes more positive behaviors in the classroom (Charles & Barr, 2014). Many teachers generally use the reward method of praise within their classrooms for a variety of reasons. The first advantage of using praise within the classroom is because it encourages students do repeat positive behaviors in the classroom. Many children are simply looking for attention and enjoy it, which makes it a great technique to use in the classroom (Charles & Barr, 2014). Another advantage for this reward type is that due to the encouragement, the students are able to perform at a better rate; students excel academically. A final advantage to using praise is that it is easily implemented into the classroom and requires little to no preparation. This makes the reward method a great addition for teachers as well as students because students get instant feedback without