Plainsong Analysis

1236 Words3 Pages

Ike and Bobby gained somewhat of a positive relationship with a lonely old woman named Mrs. Stearns, who was one of the people they delivered the paper to every week. The relationship the boys have with Iva Stearns was particularly interesting. Because they all lived in such a small town, Iva was aware of little things going on here and there within the boys’ family, things going on at school, etc. One could assume that she knew that they didn’t exactly have it easy, so she did as much as she could to take these boys under her wing, treating them as her own children (or grandchildren). Iva acted as a motherly figure for the boys, talking to them about school issues, talking about life events, and even teaches them how to make cookies at one …show more content…

Just as Terri Hamilton argues in her article, the moments where characters “make clear, undeniable impacts” on one another make stories “rich in a more realistic way” (Hamilton). In Hamilton’s personal interviews, many have argued that Plainsong is a book where “nothing dramatic, thrilling or exiting happens,” (Hamilton), although she begs to differ. As this relationship with Mrs. Stearns exhibits, the boys bond with her, and gain her trust, only to find her dead in her apartment later on in the story. Although something like this may not exactly be the most ‘exciting’ event in a story, a reader can understand the reality of the situation, and may be able to put themselves in these boys’ shoes. After dealing with their mother’s abandonment, the reader gets the sense that this woman may be able to serve as a prominent mother figure, but once again, they are left alone after her sudden death. As the boys are not quite sure how to deal with the death of Mrs. Sterns, they took a horseback ride 11 miles out of town, to see the McPheron brothers. Until this point in the story, it was not clear whether or not the Guthrie boys had a trusting relationship with Raymond and Harold, but seemingly so, they …show more content…

Her mother kicks her out; the father of her baby abandons her. The young high school girl is left alone to figure it out for herself. This girl’s life becomes stressful very quickly, for obvious reasons. Just as the saying goes, when it rains, it pours, and this is exactly what seems to be happening to Victoria. The studies conducted by the three psychology researchers make a claim that women in particular, at such a young age “may respond to extreme situations in a more depressed manner” (Chang 11). I would argue myself that falling pregnant at such a young age, having nowhere to live, and no one to support me would be especially difficult, so Victoria is definitely not in a positive state of mind. After a teacher, Maggie Jones took Victoria under her wing, and it didn’t work out so well due to her senile father’s angry confusion. Maggie asked two elderly bachelor brothers, Raymond and Harold McPheron, if they were willing to take the young girl in. Maggie made a good point, “you old solitary bastards need somebody” (Haruf 110). Harold even refers to him and his brother as “old men, alone, crotchety, ignorant. Lonesome. Independent” (Haruf 112), set in their ways. As I analyze the depressed states Victoria, I see the climax of her negative coping when she makes an impulse decision to live with her baby’s father in Denver. She went to

Open Document