Offer and Acceptance Phases of a Contract

791 Words2 Pages

Offer and Acceptance Phases of a Contract Bob owns a stamp shop in Muncaster High Street. On Monday he places an item in the advertisement column of the Muncaster Evening Gazette. ‘Utopian Penny Red Stamp, one for only, £750 or nearest offer’. Late that day, Alan, a stamp collector, telephones Bob and says ‘The Utopian Red for sale, I’ll take it for £700’. And Bob replies, ‘I cannot accept less than £725 but I will not sell it to anyone else before Saturday. Let me have a reply by Friday if you want it’. ‘That is kind of you. Remind me to buy you a drink when I see you’. On Wednesday Alan telephones Bob and leaves a message on his answering machine stating ‘I accept your offer’. Unfortunately Bob’s infant son later presses a button on the machine which erases the message before Bob listen to it. Later that day Bob sells the stamp to Cerdic for £750. On Thursday Alan meets Cerdics aged mother who tells him that she has seen Cerdic’s 9 year old son who told her that his father was very excited at having acquired a Utopian Penny Red from High Street Dealer. Alan rushes home and posts a letter to Bob confirming the message which he had left on the answering machine. On the same day Bob writes to Alan withdrawing his offer. On Friday morning Alan receives Bob’s letter and at lunchtime Bob receives Alan’s letter. Advice Alan. SUGGESTED ANSWER: In determining if it is reasonable to infer the existence of an agreement between Alan, Bob & Cerdic the language of offer and acceptance must be employed. The surrounding circumstances must be examine to ascertain if there is a firm offer followed by a final and un... ... middle of paper ... ... to the courts to verify the effectiveness of the third revocation i.e. whether Alan can rely on third party revocation. If this is possible than Alan's act of posting the letter to Bob would have no effect because the revocation has taken place earlier. On the other hand if the third party revocation is not reasonable in circumstances then when Alan post a letter to Bob confirming the message there would be an acceptance by applying the postal rule i.e. the effectiveness of the acceptance is when the letter is posted and not when it was received. Since the revocation by Bob in writing required actual communication which is by Friday but the acceptance of Alan has taken place earlier as such one could safely conclude there is an agreement between Alan and Bob if the third party revocation is not reasonable.

Open Document