Meucci Vs Graham Bell Essay

666 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: History of cellphones

Saera Sophareth
Meucci vs. Graham Bell: Final Fight

Debate continues to who should be credited with inventing the telephone. In 2002, even the US Congress succumbed to the truth and “changed its mind” on the issue gave credit to the real inventor and rewrote history that the original telephone was in fact invented by Antonio Meucci. Bell was a cunning opportunist who took all the credit for a more brilliant scientist’s work. The House of Representatives voted to recognize telecommunications genius Antonio Meucci as the father of modern communications. Credit usually goes to the person with the patent and in the history books Alexander Graham Bell as the inventor of the telephone after Bell was awarded US Patent Number 174,465, Improvement on Telegraphy, on March 7, 1876.
On April 13 1808, the eldest child of the nine children; 4 of his siblings would later die at a young age. At 15, Meucci admitted Florence Academy of Fine Arts where he became the youngest student to take mechanical and chemical engineering. Two years later, he didn’t have enough money for school to attend anymore. That did not stop him from continuing his studies by working part-time as an assistant gate-keeper and customs official for the Florentine government. Later, Antonio Meucci became employed as a stage technician at the Teatro della Pergola and assisted Artemio Canovetti. Meucci began developing the design of a “telegrafo parlante" or talking telegraph in 1849. He continues his life’s work mostly from a home lab when he moved to New York with his wife. In 1871, Meucci could not afford the $250 needed for a patent for his "talking telegraph" he filed a one-year caveat for his design instead. Due to his wife’s health, He faced financial hardship and wasn...

... middle of paper ...

...er of things but im going to guess it had something to do with medicinal bills.
Based on the articles I read it seems that Meucci had everything made and ready to go but he had to take care of his wife and then the next person Graham Bell had the chance to file it. In January 1887, Meucci sued and Bell’s patent came into question in court and the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case and fraud charges were initiated against Bell. The patent was issued on the grounds of fraud and misrepresentation. The case was discontinued when Antonio Meucci died in 1889. The legal action died with him. The Bell patent was set to expire in January 1893. On June 11, 2002, long after his death, the U.S. Congress passed House Resolution 269, introduced by Rep. Vito Fossella, which recognizes the life and achievements of Antonio Meucci, and his work in the invention of the telephone.

Show More
Related

  • Contribution of Italians to American Society

    344 Words  | 1 Pages

    name was Gian-Carlo Minotti. This man was trained in the Italian Opera and he was

    Read More

  • The Glorious Stradivari Revolution

    991 Words  | 2 Pages

    Antonio Stradivari was born in Bergamo Italy 1644. In his youth he lived in Cremona Italy, where he became the apprentice of Nicolo Amati. He had married twice, once in 1667 with a woman named Francesca, whom he had six children with. His first son only lived for six days. The rest later became priests, and apprentices of their father. Francesca then died in 1698. Soon after Stradivari remarried in 1699 to a woman named Antonia. Antonia and Stradivari had four children. Two of which had died. Stradivari bought a home in Piazza Roma; this is where Stradivari carried out his work as a luthier, with his sons at his side as apprentices. In 1737 Stradivari had died and was buried in the church of San Domenico in Cremona where his family had originated.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Victorian Internet By Tom Standage

    960 Words  | 2 Pages

    He used a comparison pattern to describe telegraph invention with the internet, and how was more important to invent this device similar to the internet invention. Reading through the book gives a different criterion of the implementation and evolution of the telegraph device in Europe and United States. Although Standage’s book lacks deep technical aspects, he tells the story of telegraph invention in simple and interesting chronical way. In fact, he started his first chapter by mentioning the rumors of inventing a magical device to transfer letter between people mile apart in the late of the sixteen century. By 1791 two French scientist brothers Claude and Rene Chappe invented the first version of the Telegraph. The working principle of this device was mechanical and optical, which had failed in the dark. The Chappe brothers continued their trials until 1793 they succeeded to invent the first dependable device to transmit messages over long distances. At this time, the telegraph first named tachygraph from the Greek word tachy which means fast, then they changed to telegraph. The new invention became fully operational by 1794, where it played an important role to send a report of the capture of town from the Austrians and Prussians. The success of using the telegraph in civilian and military matter encouraged Napoleon to build wider telegraph network by 1804. During the nineteen century, the telegraph machine evolved to a wider global communication network to cross the continents especially in England and the United States, where Samuel Morse developed a newer version of the telegraph by

    Read More

  • The History And Development Of The Bell Telephone Company

    557 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Bell Telephone Company was formed in 1877 and produced the new invention, the telephone.

    Read More

  • Biography of Samuel Morse

    570 Words  | 2 Pages

    Samuel Morse contributed many things to American society. In 1832 when returning from Europe from a period of art study on the ship Sully, Samuel overheard a conversation about the newly discovered electromagnets and came up with the idea of an electric telegraph. By 1835 he had his first telegraph model working in the New York University building. In 1837, he acquired two partners to help him develop his telegraph. Leonard Gale and Alfred Vail were the two men that he chose. They applied for a patent in 1837 for the telegraph, which included the dot and dash code.

    Read More

  • Samuel F.B. Morse

    807 Words  | 2 Pages

    Morse was a very friendly guy. Being a natural leader, he was a founder and the first president of the National Academy of Design, but was lost his campaigns to become mayor of New York or a Congressman. In 1832, while returning on the ship from another period of studying art in Europe, Morse heard a conversation about the newly discovered electromagnet and got the idea of an electric telegraph. He mistakenly thought that the idea of such a telegraph was new, helping to give him the go ahead and push the idea forward. By 1835 he probably had his first telegraph model working in the New York University building where he taught art. Being poor, Morse used materials like an old artist's canvas stretcher to hold his invention, a home-made battery and an old clock-work to move the paper on which dots and dashes were to be recorded.

    Read More

  • Lewis Latimer

    437 Words  | 1 Pages

    Lewis Latimer enlisted in the Union Navy at the age of 15 by forging the age on his birth certificate. Upon the completion of his military service, Lewis Latimer returned to Boston, Massachusetts where he was employed by the patent solicitors Crosby & Gould. While working in the office Lewis began the study of drafting and eventually became their head draftsmen. During his employment with Crosby & Gould, Latimer drafted the patent drawings for Alexander Graham Bell's patent application for the telephone, spending long nights with the inventor. Bell rushed his patent application to the patent office mere hours ahead of the competition and won the patent rights to the telephone with the help of Latimer.

    Read More

  • Bell-Smith Up And Away Essay

    438 Words  | 1 Pages

    Cory Arcangel exhibits a film called Super Mario Clouds, 2002. Arcangel hacked a cartridge of Super Mario Brothers, modified to erase everything but the clouds. It illustrates animated clouds from the game Super Mario which the clouds are gradually floating horizontally for a whole six minutes. In the next film Michael Bell-Smith, Up and Away, 2006 exhibits a multitude of colorful and animated sceneries which changed every second to seven minutes. Bell-Smith collected the beautiful and creative perspective from video games and created a slideshow with video game sound effect and calming beach music.

    Read More

  • Invention of the Phonograph

    1167 Words  | 3 Pages

    The cylinder phonograph proved to be successful, but the problem with the machine was that the tin foil only allowed a few uses. With the help of another great inventor, new advances could be made to improve this invention. The inventor of the telephone, Alexander Graham Bell, had set up a laboratory for his cousin, Chichester Bell and Charles Tainter. Bell a...

    Read More

  • Hernani, by Victor Hugo

    1091 Words  | 3 Pages

    There were also many inventions during this time. One of which is something most of us in the twenty-first century can’t live without, the telephone. It was invented in 1876 by Alexander Graham Bell (Farah 611). 69 years earlier, the first practical steamboat was designed by Robert Fulton (Farah 606). But there was more to the 1800’s than just science and inven...

    Read More

  • Impact of Telephone on Society

    1655 Words  | 4 Pages

    Although the telephone became a necessity of daily life, it was at first neglected by the public. People thought the telephone was a fake and a mere toy. Although the telephone was a powerful innovation, nobody took it seriously. Perhaps these people were ignorant because they did not realize the capabilities of the telephone. The reason for this skepticism was the revolutionary idea of communicating through a telephone, "So devastatingly new, so revolutionary, was this innovation of Bell's that a self-satisfied world wasted a good deal of time ridiculing the telephone and its inventor."1 This idea lasted for a few years, but then the public's view began to change.

    Read More

  • Have Mobile Phones Improved Communication?

    1720 Words  | 4 Pages

    On June 21, 1890, Bell and his assistant Charles Sumner invented a wireless telephone, named a photo phone. This photo phone allowed the transmission of both sound and huma...

    Read More

  • How the Telephone Changed History

    1095 Words  | 3 Pages

    On March 10th, 1876, a revolutionary invention was created by Alexander Graham Bell. The telephone was invented to send vibrations from one receiver to another electrically (History.com ‘Speech Transmitted by Telephone’ accessed on March 11, 2014), and due to Alexander Graham Bell accidentally discovering that he could hear the sound of a ‘clock spring twanging’ (Marry Bellis, ‘The History of the Telephone’ accessed on March 11, 2014), that was possible. The invention of the telephone permitted new levels of communication, allowed families connect around the world, and improved military systems, but also served negative consequences, such as breached privacy. If two people wanted to have a conversation, they would have to write letters back and forth, but with the telephone they were able to pick up the receiver, dial the number, and be connected in a matter of minutes. Telephones enabled long-distance communication, which allowed families to converse despite their location. Military officials and soldiers were also able to stay in touch through field telephones as well as keep contact with the president. Although telephones were originally placed in general stores or other major city locations and homes/neighborhoods that were wired (Elon.edu ‘World Changes Due to the Telephone’ accessed on April 2, 2014), telephones became commonly used in homes in the early twentieth century when telephones began to connect internationally.

    Read More

  • Evolution of Smartphones

    1952 Words  | 4 Pages

    Despite the short amount of time since the introduction of the smartphone, the rapid development of the software and technology has had a tremendous effect on the everyday life of society today. The concept of communicating through a telephone was developed in the 1870s. Devices to transmit speech electrically were designed by Elisha Gray and Alexander Graham Bell, but Bell's design was patented first. On March 10, 1876, Alexander Graham Bell achieved one of his greatest successes in the making of the telephone. This brought upon a major change in communication and gave leeway to the improvement of the telephone in the days to come (Bellis, 2013b).

    Read More

  • Alexander Graham Bell, Inventor of the Telephone

    698 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...he Telephone ~ Bell worked on the harmonic telegraph with his assistant, the electrician Thomas Watson. However, Bell thought of another idea; he believed that he could create a device that would transmit speech electrically. Secretly, he and Watson worked on this device. The first successful two-way conversation of clear speech by Bell and Watson was made on March 10, 1876 when Bell spoke into the device, “Mr. Watson, come here, I want to see you.” The men were jubilant after Watson heard the message and came to Bell’s side. Bell did not want to patent the device, since he believed that he needed to improve on it. However, Hubbard found out about the device and applied a patent for it without Bell’s permission. Coincidentally, Bell’s rival Elisha Gray applied for a patent for a telephone-like device, but since Bell’s patent was applied for first, he won the patent.

    Read More

More about Meucci Vs Graham Bell Essay

Open Document