Massachusetts Bay Colony Case Analysis

1304 Words3 Pages

Jheaya Conwell The History of the Colony of Province of Massachusetts Bay: Volume II was created by a male author named Thomas Hutchinson. The Massachusetts Bay Colony Case against Anne Hutchinson (1637) was edited by Lawrence Shaw Mayo who attended Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts. The selection was reprinted by the permission of Thomas Hutchinson, but in the Table of Contents it says that John Winthrop was the author of the selection. Even though he was the governor of the year 1637, and was also included in the trial case. Maybe he could have tweaked some of the things he said to Anne Hutchinson so that he did not come off as rude. Also, since Thomas and Anne Hutchinson have the same last name they could have been related, …show more content…

The excerpts are very sexist about woman and think that woman should not go on their own and believe their own beliefs. All four women within both excerpts were accused of witchcraft and charges were brought unto them. Anne Hutchinson and Susanna Martin did not clearly answer any questions they were asked and they both have some of their trial case published in the book, but they did defend themselves till the end when the people who they were talking to them tried to mix up their words. Though charges were brought to all four women, Anne Hutchinson was the only one who was executed along with some of her children. The Massachusetts Bay Colony Case was before the Salem Witchcraft Trials and maybe the Massachusetts Bay Colony Case’s punishments were harder than the Salem Witchcraft Trials excerpt. Since the Salem Witchcraft Trials was in the year of 1693. Which is Fifty-six years after the Massachusetts Bay Colony Case. Also, the Massachusetts Bay Colony Case excerpt only focused on one person which was Anne Hutchinson while Salem’s excerpt included three women. In the Salem excerpt it only had a little part of Susanna Martin’s trial case and the rest was biased information. The Massachusetts Bay Colony Case was all a trial case. Furthermore with the Salem Witchcraft Trials when the people spoke about their encounters with Susanna Martin, a lot of numbers were skipped. The numbers ranged from 1-12 and within those numbers only numbers two, four, six, seven, and twelve were in the excerpt. Following those five numbers were the people who talked about their encounter with Susanna Martin and none of them were a positive encounter. I believe the Massachusetts Bay Colony Case way more over the Salem Witchcraft Trials, because the Massachusetts Bay Colony Case was more believable just because

Open Document