Jesus Feeding The Five Thousand Rhetorical Analysis

1025 Words3 Pages

Part A: Charpentier Method
1. Read the passage for the first time
Note your reactions: When I was reading the passage of ‘Jesus feeds the Five Thousand’, I felt amazed that Jesus could use two fish and five loaves to feed five thousand people. I was also surprised that there were still twelve baskets of broken pieces of fish and bread leftover, after everyone was satisfied.
- What strikes you or puzzles you? It puzzles me that Jesus was able to feed five thousand people with only two fish and five loaves. It also puzzles me that the crowds sat in groups of hundreds and fifties, and not just in one big group.
- What do you find attractive or comforting I felt comforted when Jesus took compassion on the crowd, fed and taught them all. I liked …show more content…

Study the passage - What is happening in the text? Jesus came across a large crowd of people who were trying to see him. He had compassion on them, taught them multiple things and healed the sick among them. All they had was five loaves of bread and two fish. With these, Jesus broke the loaves and divided the fish, which the people ate and became full. There were twelve baskets of broken pieces of bread and fish leftover from the five thousand people who had eaten. - Who is doing or looking for what? Jesus healed, taught and was compassionate to the crowd. He performed a miracle and fed all five thousand people because they needed something to eat. The apostles/crowd were looking for Jesus to hear him teach, ask questions and to be reassured that Jesus will always help them and give them guidance. At the start of the passage, they were looking for Jesus to tell him all that they had done and taught.
- What are their attitudes? The apostles were satisfied and happy after eating, and Jesus had a positive attitude towards them due to the fact that he wanted them all to …show more content…

At the start of the passage, Jesus told his apostles to get some rest, but many of them saw him leaving. They ran to get to the place where he was going so they could tell him what they have done and what they have taught. At the end of the passage, Jesus had compassion on them and fed the five thousand people with only five loaves and two fish.
- Can you see any change? The change in this passage is that the apostles were hungry and had not eaten all day, because they were listening to Jesus teach. Then, they ate the bread and fish and were all satisfied and full. - How does it happen? The change occurs by Jesus looking up to heaven, giving thanks to God and then performing the miracle of feeding five thousand people with nothing but five loaves of bread and two fish. - What stages are involved? The apostles ran to where Jesus was going, Jesus has compassion and teaches them, Jesus performs the miracle by breaking the loaves and fish, the crowd are satisfied and full with their food and twelve baskets of broken bread and fish are leftover.
- Who, or what, brings about the change? Jesus is the person who brings the change because he did not let the people go and buy their own food like the disciples wanted them to, instead he fed them himself with only what they had which was five loaves and two fish. 3. Context of the

Open Document