Jake Barnes Relationship

1449 Words3 Pages

In The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway, Jake Barnes progresses from being a childish, hopeful lover of a superficial woman, Brett, to a more mature man who realizes that he and Brett will never be able to have the amorous relationship he desires. Jake and Brett are evidently in love with each other in the novel, but Jake is unable to please Brett physically because of a mysterious injury during World War I. Brett cannot be with a partner who is unable to fulfill her physical needs, leading to her relationship with Jake being tainted. Instead of being straightforward with Jake, though, Brett decides to lead Jake on throughout the novel, giving him a sliver of hope that they might marry each other. Jake, as a result, becomes a hopeful romantic …show more content…

After Jake tells Bill about Cohn and Brett’s trip to San Sebastian, Bill says that Cohn “can go to hell” and Jake agrees, saying that Bill is “damn right” (82). Although Jake is not the one who says that Cohn “can go to hell,” he is evidently thinking it as he readily agrees with Bill. Jake remains immature as he is still hurt by Cohn’s weekend with Brett, even though Cohn seems to feel remorse which is why he is acting more friendly towards Jake. In another later exchange with Bill, Jake belittles Cohn again when Bill says, “say something pitiful,” and Jake replies, “Robert Cohn” (92). Jake has always been demeaning towards Cohn, as the novel began with Jake telling the reader, “Do not think that I am very much impressed by that as a boxing title” (1). Jake’s undermining of Cohn’s achievement portrays Jake’s own insecurities and his need to feel better than Cohn. Jake calls Robert Cohn “pitiful” here, but it is Jake who seems pitiful because he is still jealous of Cohn because of his relationship with Brett. It is ironic that Jake continues to degrade Cohn because earlier in the novel, Jake said, “I do not know how people could say such terrible things to Robert Cohn” (40). Jake’s obsession with Brett and his frustration that he cannot please Brett physically make him say “terrible things” about Cohn. Jake, though, will begin to …show more content…

At the beginning of the novel, Jake is obsessed with Brett and thinks that they will end up together even though she is very unstable in relationships. By the end of the novel, Jake has accepted that he and Brett will never be together, reaching a sort of peacefulness because of his more realistic ideas about their relationship. Although pain still lingers because he cannot have his true love, Jake has matured enough that he can begin to appreciate other aspects of life and not be so focused on Brett. In the novel, Hemingway depicts the emotional weight that relationships bring onto people and how they can relieve themselves or free themselves from that

Open Document