Holden Caulfield Satire

950 Words2 Pages

Goddamn Purgatory: Holden’s Search for the Significance of Life in The Catcher in the Rye The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger, set in New York City in the mid-1900’s, tells the story of Holden Caulfield, a teenage boy who flunks out of Pencey, a well-known boarding school, and flees to the city. At Pencey, Holden is surrounded by people whose self-worth is derived from good grades and athleticism. Holden's values differ from those of his peers, and are based on finding truth within himself, within others, and within the world, leaving him isolated and without meaningful connection. This difference of values pushes him to analyze and criticize the meaning that his peers find through their obedient natures and their conventionality, in …show more content…

When Holden internally reflects on the nuns whilst they are eating their simple meals of toast and coffee, he “could tell, for one thing, that they never went anywhere swanky for lunch. It made [him] so damn sad…” (62). Although these nuns are without money, their happiness is portrayed in the pure simplicity of their lifestyle. The sadness Holden feels towards the nuns’ simple lifestyle while at the same time yearning for it, shows how complexity is embedded deep inside of him. Holden is very wealthy and presumably has always had the luxury to go to fancy restaurants for lunch, yet because of the value placed on his materialistic experiences, he never had the luxury to explore himself to find inner peace and acceptance. While Holden’s mind is a rich jumble of unclear ideas and unconnected connectedness, the nun’s minds are clear and they know what they are living for; they have a clear purpose. Holden’s extreme interest to talk to these nuns about life, and the flow of the interaction they have with each other, shows how Holden is eager to find any insight or clarity on the truths of the …show more content…

After he gets in a fight with Stradlater, Holden, face covered in blood, wakes up Ackley by saying, “Listen. What's the routine on joining a monastery? . . . Do you have to be a Catholic and all?" (27). Although Holden is not Catholic, he wants to be part of a community of like-minded people who understand each other on a deeper level. Catholics in monasteries don’t only agree with each other on a basic belief level, but their spiritualities are connected because of their understandings and interpretations of the world and occurrences in the world. At Pencey, and at the other boarding schools Holden has attended, violence has been validated and not hitting back has been considered weak. Holden’s values differ so greatly from those of his peers and he is stranded on an island, yearning to be part of a like-minded community, unlike the community of Pencey. Holden wants to find a way to connect with people who understand him and who he understands, and believes that he may find this within the monastery on his path to

Open Document