Holden Caulfield Innocence

1973 Words4 Pages

True innocence is defined as the absence of experience; where one is pure and trusts the idealism of the world. More often than not, this innocence is shattered as one gains insight into the reality of mankind. The Catcher in the Rye, by J.D Salinger, along with, The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, by Junot Diaz, questions the innocence of reality through the eyes of both Holden Caulfield and Oscar Wao respectively. Holden’s quest to see the true reality of the adult world is shaped by the influence of his sister, Phoebe and the people he encounters during his journey. In comparison, Oscar’s teenage years of life create struggle by convincing him he does not fit the required stereotype necessary to live a happy life. Through eye opening experiences …show more content…

[…] Sucks to be left out of adolescence, sort of like getting locked in a closet,” (Diaz, 23). The whole reasoning behind Oscar’s alienation originates from his “unnatural” transition of a young boy to a mature man. Oscar’s subpar appearance and minimal confidence leads him to believe it is best for him to stay isolated from others in order to protect himself from embarrassment. Both characters deal with diverse problems leading to the conclusion of alienation as being the best solution to deal with them. Oscar and Holden both look towards closing themselves off from society in order to deal with the problems they cannot face on their …show more content…

When Holden leaves Pencey in search of the idealism of the adult world, he comes across many conversations in which it is very evident he is desperate for affection. Both physical and emotional situations serve as a scapegoat to Holden providing a way to for him come out of his isolated shell. However, Holden’s desire for love and sexuality has a certain limit before which it becomes a fear. When Holden is faced with the situation of a prostitute in his hotel room, he has the chance to engage in sexual intercourse, but instead, he sees the innocence in the prostitute and repels away from sex. Right after she lifts her dress over her head, Holden asks, “Are you in a very big hurry?” (Salinger, 124), she looks at him like a madman yelling, “What the heck ya wanna talk about?” (Salinger, 124). Holden’s desire for sexuality is non-existent where it is evident his only wish is to share a certain level of intimacy with individuals before he reaches a stage of uncomfortableness. Conversely, Oscar shares both the same feeling for intimacy and sexuality as Holden but, Oscar’s desire for both is much greater. Oscar is constantly surrounded by Dominican Men, which only attributes to the constant reminder that Oscar cannot attract woman. This inability to share a level of intimacy with females drives Oscar into an even

Open Document