Gentlemen Your Verdict Character Analysis

877 Words2 Pages

Lieutenant Commander Oram and Captain John Adam are lethal weapons. These characters are leaders, kings of their castles. With emotions like storms that cloud their thoughts, makes hard decisions similar to escaping from quicksand. Below us, the submarine of Michael Bruce’s “Gentlemen, Your Verdict” lies helpless at the bottom of the ocean, Commander Oram must decide whether fifteen innocent men should die for five to live or if all twenty men will die from oxygen deprivation. Trusted by his crew with anything and everything, he is the Albus Dumbledore of his submarine: Colin McDougal’s The Firing Squad focuses on protagonist Captain John Adam, who is asked to be the executioner of a prisoner he feels innocent and with whose execution he disagrees. The characters in question are both placed in different situations, yet can be compared and contrasted through their moral dilemmas, tough decisions and their military …show more content…

Captain Adam is not doing his job and does not do what he was ordered to do and can, therefore, be punished. This was something he has to do in order to escape his racing mind and therefore is the right decision for him and his well-being. In Gentlemen, Your Verdict, the deaths Oram is responsible for is taken to court because the families of those who were lost wanted justice. Although the story does not reach a point of conviction, we can infer that he would not be charged for murder. Ethically he made the right decision, but also the decision that was right for himself. In the following quote, the surviving men are asked by the head of the court, “Gentlemen, it is for you to decide, guilty or not guilty” (24). Consequently, we can infer that the survivors would see their saviour as a hero and end up not convicting him guilty. Assuredly, we know that both men make the right decision because there are survivors in a situation where men may have been condemned to

Open Document