Genesis 1-3 Essay

836 Words2 Pages

In Genesis 1-3 there are two different stories of creation each written by a different author. There are two helpful methods in understanding the meaning: the historical-critical method and the theological method. Each method examines the stories of The Bible in different contexts. On one hand, the historical-critical method assumes that there is historical information that can be found within the bible, whereas the theological approach assumes that the bible was written as a self-revelation of God. While reading the bible in a historical-critical approach, readers are interested in information such as, who wrote this story, when were they alive, why did they write this story, or where did this happen. Theological critics argue that the most …show more content…

Interestingly, this version of creation is written after Genesis 2-3. Historical-critical thinkers would be interested to know why a second version would be written after the original; these scholars would examine who the author was, why they were writing this account, and when it was written. According to The New American Bible, Israelis wrote the first story of creation (Genesis 1) after they lost ten of their twelve tribes. They wrote this to show that Gods control is greater than human power, and their misfortunes did not mean that God had lost control (New American Bible, RG 52). With this knowledge a reader using the historical-critical method would now have information about the culture and reason for Genesis 1 being placed before the original creation story. It should be noted, however, that this hold little religious weight and is generally used when finding historical connections to the stories. While Genesis 1 was written in a time of despair, Genesis 2-3 was written at the peak of the Davidic Monarchy (“Yahwist Source” 1). In Genesis 2-3 we see the beginning of sin in humankind. While it is known who wrote the text, a historical-critical scholar would begin to infer why it had been written. In this example it is possible that the people during prosperous time became greedy and no longer followed God’s teachings. The Yahwist writers may have been motivated to write the creation story in Genesis 2-3 as a way to show that God has the power to punish all humankind for

Open Document