Examples Of Phoniness In Catcher In The Rye

1213 Words3 Pages

Holden Caulfield is every parent’s worst nightmare. From his unwillingness to come to terms with, and take responsibility for, his future to his inability to see past the flaws of others, Holden dooms himself to social and professional failure. After flunking out of his third boarding school, he wanders the streets of New York in order to avoid confronting his parents about his academic performance. Although he has an extraordinary support system, as well as countless interactions that ultimately shape his perspective of the world, Holden finds himself growing more and more depressed. In J. D. Salinger’s Catcher in the Rye, isolation is the root of Holden’s unhappiness. Holden is in desperate need of connection, yet his cynical outlook …show more content…

For the entirety of the book, Holden accuses others of phoniness, yet he completely disregards his own superficiality. Concerning his refusal to take responsibility for his education, Mr. Spencer, Holden’s history teacher, explains to Holden that “life is a game one plays according to the rules” (11). After quickly agreeing with supposed sincerity, Holden silently contradicts everything Mr. Spencer has just stated. He mentally retorts that if one lives in a world of privileged “hot-shots,” life is certainly a game. “On the other side,” however, “where there aren’t any hot-shots,” then nothing is “a game about it” (11). Additionally, Holden lies to the mother of arguably the most hated and obnoxious student at Pencey. Solely out of a need to avoid confrontation and keep others content, Holden insists that “he’s one of the most popular boys at Pencey” and is simply too modest to run for class elections (63). Holden grows so engrossed in the undesirable characteristics of others that he overlooks the stream of perpetual, wild lies in which he is constantly stuck. Frequently, Holden finds himself lying about his age in order to appeal to “dopey girls” with whom “it is practically impossible” to engage in “a little intelligent conversation” (80, 82). Not only does Holden lack self-awareness regarding his fakeness, but he refuses to accept his inevitable entrance into the adult world. With each passing, influential experience, Holden clings more to the past and hopes to prevent others from landing in the same predicament that he now faces: the loss of his innocence. He dreads change, as becomes evident in the Natural History museum when he discusses the most appealing aspect of the museum: the fact that “everything always stayed right where it was. Nobody’d move” (135). Because Holden is so dependant on

Open Document