Evaluation of the Claim that Conscience is a Realiable Guide in Ethical Decision Making

1793 Words4 Pages

Evaluation of the Claim that Conscience is a Realiable Guide in Ethical Decision Making In order to decide whether or not our consciences can be relied upon, we must first examine what we mean by conscience. In order for conscience to be consistently and absolutely reliable, infallible, it must stem from an infallible source - God. Alternatively, conscience might have a potential of ultimate reliability, if the faculty of conscience was dynamic and capable of solving problems i.e. if it was an innate part of human nature. Conscience could even be totally fallible - an arbitrary by-product of experience and biology. This idea - propagated by such scientist-thinkers as Sigmund Freud and Piaget - does not dismiss the idea of conscience, but rather seeks to define it in psychoanalytical terms. Freud had a different word for the conscience - Super-Ego. In order to understand this concept, we must delve briefly into Freud's general psychological theories. According to Freud, every child is born with the 'Id'. The Id is that part of us which is based solely on the pleasure principle - ignoring all reality it seeks food, shelter or other physical gratification. As a child develops he or she will begin to realise that the needs of the Id cannot always be met, whether because of the restraints of physical reality or the emotional impact that the demands of the Id will have on others. This part of the psyche is called the Ego. The Super-Ego, Freud believed, was a collection of beliefs and values enforced on a child's psyche by his parents and the prevailing consensus in the society which surrounded him or her. The super-ego remain... ... middle of paper ... ...es which consider conscience arbitrary or habitual tend to not believe in moral absolutes - which absolves the question of ethical decision of the weight otherwise ascribed to it. In other words, a relative view of conscience correlates with a relative view of ethics. Conscience is the most reliable, and mst useful, tool we have for making ethical decisions. --------------------------------------------------------------------- © Jonathan May-Bowles - All work should be this colorful. Sponsored by the Campaign For Interesting Looking Work™ (02-10-02) © Jonathan May-Bowles - All work should be this colorful. Sponsored by the Campaign For Interesting Looking Work™ (02-10-02) © Jonathan May-Bowles - All work should be this colorful. Sponsored by the Campaign For Interesting Looking Work™ (02-10-02)

Open Document