Essay Compare And Contrast Book And Movie

486 Words1 Page

Personal Response: I enjoyed both the movie and the book. The first time I saw this movie was when it came out in 2005 and being that I was only familiar with the Gene Wilder version, not the actual book, I did not care for the Johnny Depp version. However, as I followed along with my book while I watched the movie I was so surprised at how closely they followed the book. So much of the movie dialogue is taken straight from the text. I was even unable to find differences between the book and the movie in the section where they are in the nut room and Veruca decides to get a squirrel to take home. I also very much enjoyed reading the song lyrics in the book and realizing they are the same lyrics in the movie! For me, that was so exciting to …show more content…

The movie does a good job using the lyrics from the song in the book, but there are a lot of lines not used. I think children would enjoy singing the entire song in the same style it is sung in the movie. Another cross curriculum activity would to study, like Mike says, the difference between particles and waves and how televisions really function. Televisions are something most children have access to and have watched and I think it would be a fun science tie in. The third activity I thought about was a reader’s theater for the book. I would split my students into groups and assign each group a certain part of the book and have them recreate for the class their section. You could even tie in the music activity into this section as well by having them sing the song (or another group) in their section. Finally, I might tie in a social studies and science lesson by having my students trace how a cocoa bean becomes a bar of chocolate. They can research where cocoa is grown (geography,) how it is grown (science,) learn about fair trade vs. non fair trade, imports and exports, supply and demand (economics) as well as the process that happens when the cocoa beans finally make it to the factory

Open Document