Edwidge Danticat's Brother I M Dying

926 Words2 Pages

Brother, I’m Dying, is Edwidge Danticat’s nonfiction about family story that centers around her father, her uncle, and the events that linked them to the last of their lives. Danticat used the event of her father has end-stage pulmonary fibrosis and she is pregnant with her first child as a frame of her memoir. Danticat’s information is taken “from official documents, as well as borrowed recollections of family members” (Danticat 25). Danticat tells the story of the men she loved only because they can’t (26). “The blueberry picking” is a Donald Hall’s memoir collected in String Too Short to be Saved. It’s a memoir of the summer that he spent time with his grandparents’ New Hampshire farm when he was a boy. “The blueberry picking” takes the …show more content…

The first time that Hall shows the kind of love is, when he asked his grandfather “Is there any water on the way?” and his grandfather turned to him with dead white face, he was shocked. Hall asked his grandfather “Are you all right?” and offer himself to carry the yoke (Hall 109). Hall shows his care to his grandfather by helped him carry the heavy yoke that fulfill with blueberries, not once but many times. I came back to my grandfather. He was examining his hands again and did not hear me coming. I saw how old his hands looked. Then he looked over at the yoke. “Do you really feel like carrying that?” he asked. “Sure I do” (Hall 115). Another theme that shows in both memoirs is, journey. Brother, I’m Dying deals primarily with the separation of family members across years and miles, it become a central role. Danticat experiences this in different ways at different times during her life. For example, she leaved Haiti to New York when she was a child, and she moved away from her family New York to Miami to live with her husband. Her father points out: Your mother’s here in Brooklyn. I’m here. Two of your three brothers are here. You have no family in Miami. What if this man you’re moving there for mistreats you? Who are you going to turn to? (Danticat …show more content…

Danticat asks her uncle why he never tried to move to New York like her father did, he said “It’s not easy to start over in a new place. Exile is not for everyone. Someone has to stay behind, to receive the letters and greet family members when they come back” (Danticat 140) He does finally settle in the United States, but only when he is dead. Journey plays a big part in “The blueberry picking” as Hall’s memoir is all about leaving his grandparents house to the top Ragged Mountain where wild blueberries grow. The purpose is not just to pick up the blueberries but his grandfather wanted to show him and tell some story of their family “Many people of your blood stepped on that stone,” he said. That’s the doorstep, and there the cellar hole. Uncle Luther grew up here, and your Great-Grampa Benjamin, and the others before him (Hall 114). Finally, the style that both Danticat and Hall use is first-person point of view. Because the story that they are telling are their own, they use the first person “I” throughout. This gives a sense of immediacy, clarity, and honesty in a nonfiction work. Tn their own voice, Danticat and Hall organize these narratives in a story told through a personal

Open Document