Eagles Theory In Lord Of The Ring

1080 Words3 Pages

“‘Farewell,’ they cried, ‘Wherever you fare till your eyries receive you at the journey 's end!’ That is the polite thing to say among Eagles. ‘May the wind under your wings bear you where the sun sails and the moon walks,’ answered Gandalf, who knew the correct reply.” (J.R.R. Tolkien, The Hobbit, or There and Back Again) For those reading this who are familiar with Lord of the Rings, one has heard the classic “Eagles theory.” This theory states that before Gandalf died, he had planned for the Fellowship to take the Eagles to Mordor, and when he came back as Gandalf the White he had forgotten about it (Covucci “A Thorough Rebuttal to the ‘Why Didn’t the Eagles Just Fly Frodo to Mordor’ LOTR Complaint”) While this theory makes sense for those …show more content…

Now within this context, if one sees a huge bird that is not native to the area flying towards the only place in the world where that ring can be destroyed, with its power lost forever, someone is bound to notice and tell the original someone who lost the ring. This is what would have happened in Lord of the Rings if the Fellowship tried to take the Eagles to Mordor. Sauron, the maker of the ring, had many spies all over Middle Earth looking for the ring and reporting back to him. Not only would finding this ring give Sauron the ability to enslave everyone in Middle Earth, it would also grant him a new body. This is why Gandalf elected to have a small and quick group to take the ring, as to not draw attention to themselves. If the Fellowship used the Eagles instead of horseback riding and walking, they would have been quickly and easily detected. Sauron would have sent the Nazgûl flying on their Fellbeasts to go after the Fellowship and take the ring back. This is assuming the Eagles themselves had not yet been corrupted by the ring’s …show more content…

According to the Iowa National Heritage Foundation, both mother and father eagle are protective over the eaglets. While the Eagles in Lord of the Rings are divine creatures, they are still animals with natural animal instincts. They care more about their babies than anything else in middle earth. If the parents die, they cannot protect the eaglets. While the Eagles like Gandalf, they would not put themselves in harm’s way. Rescuing Gandalf from Saruman’s tower did not put them in danger, neither did rescuing Frodo and Sam from Mordor after the ring was destroyed. The Eagles put their children first, like any good parent

Open Document