Dylan Roofs

673 Words2 Pages

Forgiveness is incredible. The ability of a human being to summon up the power within themselves to not harbor vengeance and anger in their heart over the wrongs done to them, including traumatic, painful wrongs, is stunning. A person struggles not to admire someone with perpetual forgiveness in their hearts; however, at the same time, forgiveness is not the only way. Although forgiveness is incredible, human beings are not obliged to forgive and are not less righteous for not forgiving. Both Roxane Gay and Sophronia Scott engaged the topic of forgiveness with eloquence, intelligence, and ultimately, differing opinions; ultimately, I find myself somewhere between the two of them. While I do not believe that we should allow anger and resentment …show more content…

As Gay mentions in her piece, because of the racism involved in Roof’s murder that still persists and affects and hurts black people after the crime, his action is not forgivable (Why I Can’t Forgive Dylan Roof 4). If an event is still ongoing or a digression is part of a larger issue, then forgiveness is not possible. One cannot forgive someone who continues repeatedly to hurt them; after a point, apologies mean nothing, and sometimes they are never said. Because Roof’s action is tied to a systemic issue as opposed to a random incident, Gay sees no means of forgiving Roof. Forgiveness does not solve every issue, especially when the wrong in question is a part of an ongoing issue. Change was not brought about in the Civil Rights movement via forgiveness; instead change was brought about because people, primarily black people were angry; they were angry over the injustices faced by the likes of Rosa Parks, Emmett Till, Linda Brown, and millions more. Forgiveness would not give them their long withheld rights; nor would it give them the peace in the outside world they …show more content…

My brother is violent and aggressive; I have gone into school having mental breakdowns because of him. I have watched him hurt my father, my mother, and myself. What hurt me the most, sometimes, however was that I could not let go of my desire to forgive him, my desire to love him the same way I loved him when he was younger. In my senior year of high school, my guidance counselor told me that I was not obliged to love someone who hurt me, that I was to put my safety first, and that message resonates with me and this prompt. Sometimes, forgiveness can take more of a toll than anger, especially in cases where one is attempting to forgive someone who continually hurts them. Racism continually has hurt black Americans, and I believe that black people and other people of color have the full right to deny forgiveness to racists. Although I concur that too much anger can be a bad thing, ultimately I believe that in some cases, forgiveness is not the

Open Document