Double Indemnity Book Vs Movie Essay

1127 Words3 Pages

Double Indemnity is a crime novel that was written by author and journalist, James M. Cain. The plot of Double Indemnity is about an insurance salesman by the name of Walter Huff who fell in love with the married woman, Phyllis Nirdlinger. Throughout the novel, both Huff and Nirdlinger pursue their love for each other and faces the drama from everyone around them. The novel was successful enough that Hollywood adapted the book into a film in 1944. The film Double Indemnity would then be directed by Billy Wilder with the assistance of Raymond Chandler. Eventually, the film became successful and was nominated for several Academy Awards. Despite the successful ending, the film had to find ways to either bypass or follow the rules of Hollywood’s …show more content…

The Production Code prevents any film from being produced if it deviates too far from the Production Code’s guidelines for keeping the public audience safe. According to the author of “Blackout”, Sheri Chinen Biesen, the film took eight years to meet the Production Code’s requirements. In the fourth Chapter of “Blackout”, Biesen states that one of Hollywood’s objection towards the production of the film is how it sets a plan on how to conduct the perfect murder and gets away with it. According to Biesen, the story of Double Indemnity “. . . so many aspects of Cain’s story violated the Production Code that he was “compelled to reject” any consideration of it for studio production” (Biesen, p. 99), which would mean the original story would not fall under the Production Code’s guideline. Along with the head of the Production Code, Joseph Breen’s opinion on the matter, he confirmed that the original ending of Double Indemnity could not be produced and aired to the public …show more content…

In the novel, both Walters and Phyllis are implied to committed suicide together by jumping off the back of the ship during night time, as stated in the novel, “I didn’t hear the stateroom door open, but she’s beside me now while I’m writing. I can feel her. The moon” (Cain, p. 327), to show the last sentences Walter wrote in his “autobiography”. The ending is left to the readers’ interpretation on how the film ended, such as what does the moon mean, did they really commit double suicide, etc. Compared to the film’s interpretation of the ending, it shows Walters limping his way towards the elevator, only to fall due to blood loss from the bullet wound. Then Keyes called an ambulance to assist Walters and later gives one last cigarette light to Walters before the screen fades to black. While the audience may not know what truly happens to Walter in the end, at least there is a form of closure with his character with Keyes rather than how ambiguous he was portrayed in the

Open Document