David Brooks Dignity And Sadness In The Working Class Analysis

829 Words2 Pages

In the world of rhetoric, the use of the past tense is often associated with the purpose of placing blame. But, there is one columnist who would probably associate it with more constructive connotations. David Brooks is a columnist for the New York Times; he tend to write about contemporary issues within the United States. Brook’s displays a slightly paradoxical style that is critical, yet light and sympathetic. He accomplishes this primarily through the use of history and the ethos of his sources which simultaneously works as an appeal to the pathos of the audience. Brooks’s columns seem to pertain to a very nostalgic tone. This tone comes from the antithesis of the past versus the present where the present is broken and the past provides …show more content…

He does so by using the ethos of other people in order to target the pathos of the audience in situations where he would normally not be able to. For example, in his article “Dignity and Sadness in the Working Class,” Brooks was trying to appeal to the fear adults have growing up in the modern working class as well as the sadness of the elderly being abandoned by it. In this context, Brooks’s ethos as a successful writer is no good, so what does he do? He goes back to the past to tell the story of an elderly man that the audience could find more relatable. After telling the story, Brooks seems more sincere in his attempts at sympathy. For instance, he addresses the pathos of his audience which consists of “older people who feel unneeded” and “younger people who feel lost.” With the use of sympathy he is able to blend in his critiques without coming off as offensive. Brook’s true critique is that people “can’t get along with each other” in the modern working class. He persuades the audience by associating positive emotions with how the working class used to be, or “under the old seniority-based factory rules.” This approach is very similar to his other article because the ethos of MLK sympathizes with the audience of African American athletes while persuading them to change their

Open Document