Darmok at Tanagra Cunningham and Kehle at Bloomington Gauss With Chalk in Hand

1147 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: How is constructivism applied in a mathematics classroom in primary schools

Darmok at Tanagra Cunningham and Kehle at Bloomington Gauss With Chalk in Hand

This essay is the first of three short reflexive papers intended to identify the issues and implications that result from viewing mathematics education through a semiotic lens. By mathematics education I mean to include consideration of mathematics itself as a discipline of on-going human activity, the teaching and learning of mathematics, and any research that contributes to our understanding of these preceding enterprises. More specifically my current interests are in disentangling the confusion among the mathematics education community regarding the epistemological foundations of mathematics, the meaning and usefulness of constructivism as a theory of learning, and how these two issues are related to the learning and teaching of formal mathematical proof. Because I have found interdisciplinary approaches to the study of most anything both more fruitful and more enjoyable, I will employ such strategies in these papers. As a result, it may not always be clear that mathematics education is my main concern--please rest assured that it is and that if I gain insight of value in that domain I will do my best to render to Caesar what is his.

When Captain Picard and the Enterprise meet the Tamarians they encounter a communication problem that is eventually revealed by Data and Troi to be due to the Tamarians' "unusual", or as a less diplomatic Federation member might say "impaired", ability to use abstraction. Furthermore, as Raphael Carter points out on his WWW site, Data skates on even thinner ice when he concludes that a Tamarian's ego structure doesn't allow for what we think of as self identity. As a result the Tamarians communicate by citing hig...

... middle of paper ...

... between subjective and objective, and deciding whether the Tamarians' language consists of an objectivist model ala Lakoff and Johson (1980).

Trying to structure a situation in terms of such a consistent set of metaphors is in part like trying to structure that situation in terms of an objectivist model. What is left out are the experiential bases of the metaphors and what the metaphors hide. (p.220)

Works Cited:

Kieren, T., Gordon-Calvert, L., Reid, D. & Simmt, E. (1995). An enactivist research approach to mathematical activity: Understanding, reasoning, and beliefs. Paper presented at the meeting of the Ame rican Educational Research Association, San Francisco.

Lakoff, G. and Johnson, M. (1980). Metaphors we live by. Chicago: University of Chicago Press

Varela, F.J. , Thompson, E., and Rosch, E. (1992). The embodied mind. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Show More
Related

  • Why College Should be Cheaper

    1910 Words  | 4 Pages

    Steen, Lynn Arthur . "Integrating School Science and Mathematics: Fad or Folly?." St. Olaf College. (1999): n. page. Web. 12 Dec. 2013..

    Read More

  • Metaphors: History as Roots

    1141 Words  | 3 Pages

    Metaphors create meaning by “mapping [an experience] from the source domain to the target domain” (Lakoff, 1986, p. 216). For the history as roots metaphor, the source domain is roots while the target domain is history. The knowledge we have about each domain and their corresponding elements allows us to assemble a metaphor.

    Read More

  • Metaphors In The Vietnam War

    2551 Words  | 6 Pages

    metaphors alone? The use of metaphors in war and everyday life is common and an

    Read More

  • Plate Tectonics

    1326 Words  | 3 Pages

    He came back with evidence to support his claim of plate tectonics. Wegener and his expedition brought back rock structures, fossils, and evidence of ancient climates. When it came to rock structures, Wegener looked for the similarities of the rocks found along coastlines and the mountain belts found on the continents. They looked at the mountain belts of the Appalachian Mountains and the Caledonian Mountains in Scandinavia and the British Isles. These two continuous belts contained similar rock structures and the ages of these rocks matched the on both ends of the African and South American continents. Wegener also found evidence of massive climatic changes. He researched and found out that ancient glacial deposits were found indicating that ice sheets covered a large part of the Southern Hemisphere, India and Australia. He furthered explained that the Northern Hemisphere was near the equator supporting the idea of coal deposits being located there.

    Read More

  • Metaphors We Live By written by Lakoff and Johnson

    857 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...hings we cannot change but have to accept, all build our experiences. This umwelt of our existence structures our experiences and is what we use to create metaphors. "The essence of metaphor is understanding and experiencing one kind of thing in terms of another.S (Lakoff and Johnson, P. 5) To find meaning in our experiences we construct metaphors. These allow us to explain the past and to predict the future. Religion is a system of metaphors which helps us to create meaning out of life. To believe in a certain religion requires us to adopt it's metaphors.

    Read More

  • Odysseus The Sirens In Homer's The Odyssey

    708 Words  | 2 Pages

    It is important to understand that in real life experience can connect to so many things. A book is not just a book, a book is a pathway that allows the mind to make connections. A couple chapters can be describing one’s childhood as a whole book can make a person reminisce about their young adulthood. Authors are not using metaphors accidentally but on purpose. Some authors write books, but some may think they are writing to them. They are retelling somebody’s story that happen in their life. These great metaphors is a key that opens up a door to millions of

    Read More

  • Donald Davidson's What Metaphors Mean

    6928 Words  | 14 Pages

    Our literal understandings of a word are twins in constant opposition with one another, twins in constant competition to receive the most love from their mother and father. Let us pretend the parents are the literary community that demonstrates love frequently by showing a preference for one of their twins. Donald Davidson's theory expressed in What Metaphors Mean is a tragic, intellectual miscarriage; it is a theory of language that brings forth a stillborn child, a dead metaphor.

    Read More

  • Biochemistry Admission Essay

    455 Words  | 1 Pages

    Ever since I was a young girl, I have always been intrigued by the new discoveries constantly being made in order to understand our complex bodies. The beauty of our body's internal biochemistry enables us to continue living every day and it is constantly evolving without being aware of it. By observing our body at a microscopic level, I can see the biological activities and responses being created which is strongly associated with our bodies’ internal chemical reactions. This strong relationship fascinates me since the study of microorganisms intertwines with chemical reactions within our system. As an aspiring medical biochemist, the University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign will allow me to immerse my passion through its rigorous biochemistry

    Read More

  • Metaphors and Conceptual Systems

    2033 Words  | 5 Pages

    ...e category is understood for our purposes in a given context”(p. 163-63). Again, for Lakoff and Johnson there is no such thing as truth independent of human understanding.

    Read More

  • Maslow's Theory Of Employees

    1437 Words  | 3 Pages

    One way to understand the individual and motivational methods is to revisit Maslow’s hierarchy of needs (Maslow 1954). In business it is approached as a model for defining motivation. A model for understanding the needs of the individuals, considerate to all disciplines. It continues to be utilized for understanding the driving forces and what is important to the individual.

    Read More

  • Nanotechnology Case Study

    721 Words  | 2 Pages

    Parra worked as a microbiologist for a local pharmaceutical company for over two years after graduating with her bachelor’s degree in molecular and microbiology from UCF in 2011. She was interested in going back to school when she received an email from Huo about the new nanotechnology program starting at UCF.

    Read More

  • My Philosophy of Mathematics Teaching and Learning

    1307 Words  | 3 Pages

    As a secondary subject, society often views mathematics a critical subject for students to learn in order to be successful. Often times, mathematics serves as a gatekeeper for higher learning and certain specific careers. Since the times of Plato, “mathematics was virtually the first thing everyone has to learn…common to all arts, science, and forms of thought” (Stinson, 2004). Plato argued that all students should learn arithmetic; the advanced mathematics was reserved for those that would serve as the “philosopher guardians” of the city (Stinson, 2004). By the 1900s in the United States, mathematics found itself as a cornerstone of curriculum for students. National reports throughout the 20th Century solidified the importance of mathematics in the success of our nation and its students (Stinson, 2004). As a mathematics teacher, my role to educate all students in mathematics is an important one. My personal philosophy of mathematics education – including the optimal learning environment and best practices teaching strategies – motivates my teaching strategies in my personal classroom.

    Read More

  • Microbiology Essay

    1267 Words  | 3 Pages

    I have been in awe of the natural biological phenomena involved in the complex processes of the life. My inquisitive nature prompted me to read about biological processes which helped me understand how small change could be responsible in creating a disease state. Fascination regarding the cause of these diseases encouraged me to pursue Microbiology. The years spent undertaking the undergraduate studies at The Y.C. College of Science, Shivaji University (lndia), was a pivotal phase of my life that significantly shaped my career. lt was during this period that I developed liking for Microbiology and Molecular biology and which made process of learning enjoyable and interesting. The inclination towards research in this

    Read More

  • Alfred Wegener and the Continental Drift

    693 Words  | 2 Pages

    While looking at his friend’s atlas in 1910 Alfred noticed that the coastlines of the Brazil and West Africa looked as though they fit together (Conniff, 2012, para. 4). This thought did not leave his mind and he continued to research the idea. Wegener cut out the pictures of the maps and pieced them together like a puzzle. He located evidence of similar plants, animals, and other species on the Australian and South American continents to support his hypothesis.

    Read More

  • Teacher Motivation

    1346 Words  | 3 Pages

    (Slavin, Pg.286) Motivation is an important factor that teachers can focus on in order to improve learning. There are numerous theories that can help explain motivation. There is no wrong or right theory to relate to motivation, they all have a little truth in them. Very little learning can happen unless students are motivated on an everyday basis, and I experienced it in my observations. Teachers could try to a variety of tactics to enrich student motivation. When students are motivated they pay attention, they begin working on tasks immediately, they ask questions and volunteer answers, and they appear to be happy and

    Read More

More about Darmok at Tanagra Cunningham and Kehle at Bloomington Gauss With Chalk in Hand

Open Document