Cruelty In Hwee Tan's Foreign Bodies

1566 Words4 Pages

The world sucks. Without question, on a daily basis horrendous things happen. If someone could stop these from happening, the world would be a better place. However, if this person consistently chose to do nothing, ze would be considered an accessory to the crimes. Surely, ze would face the judgment of all those who know of the act. It might even be said that a person who allows rape and murder to occur without intervention does not deserve to live. Yet, by believing in an omnipotent being, one is forced to submit to a God who allows these act of cruelty. In the book Foreign Bodies by Hwee Hwee Tan, the author presents a diverse set of characters who deal with this theodicy through their own theological positions. By the end of the novel, Mei …show more content…

Andy indicates he was raised Christian, but “has never prayed seriously before, [he] never really felt he needed God to hear [his] words.” His first encounter with God occurs after being lost in Fellensham. He begs God to “give [Andy] a little direction.” Andy encounters God and the glory of Heaven after asking for God’s direction. Even after this experience, Andy goes through college “know[ing] that God doesn’t exist.” But without a God, Andy struggles to find meaning in life. At university Andy wants a world “where Jesus saves” and where “God overwhelm[s Andy] for once.” The mystical encounter from his past is not enough evidence for him; Andy wants hard proof. It is not until Mei brings him her story of when she first felt God within her that Andy accepts Christianity. This God is not the same as Mei’s God, though, as Andy believes that God interacts with humans individually on a daily basis. The reader first sees this when Andy is arrested and certain that “[God] won’t let [Andy] take the fall for something [he] didn’t do.” This shows that Andy believes in a God that intervenes with the world -- opposed to Mei’s view of a God who judges humanity after they leave the mortal world. Again, Andy divulges a more human involved God when he writes a letter to Mei addressing God in the final chapter. The God Andy addresses is not just one of good, though. Andy indicates that God will hurt him, meaning that God is …show more content…

Andy is forced to admit that not everything that God does is good. But Andy reasons that it does not have to be. He should love God because no matter what Andy does, God will continue to love him. This love can be compared to Mei’s love for God because they are both based on the concept that God sees everyone as perfect. Andy’s love, though, has to deal with the acceptance of a God that does evil things. In a way, his God acts yahwisticly as He interacts with humans and seems to have human like traits like rage. Even though this seems like a harsh reality to accept, it makes Andy’s life significantly more blissful. By accepting that God is the ultimate cause of the evil as well as the good in the world, Andy chooses not to worry about the evils. Andy’s God works as a sedative to the poor hand Andy’s been dealt. Religion is acting as the “sigh of the oppressed creature” or “the heart” of Andy’s “heartless world.” Sitting in a cell, Andy doesn’t have much to look forward to in his life. God acts as an escape for Andy -- an opium to his painful life. Andy cannot get mad about the evils of his life because he would have to get mad at a God who Andy knows loves him unconditionally. Thus, Andy is free to flow through life without caring for the unfair position he is in. Andy’s God significantly justifies the life

Open Document