Comparison Of Alice Munro's The Bear Came Over The Mountain

835 Words2 Pages

Alice Munro has built a career on creating narratives that bring so much complexity amidst its characters as well as remaining true to the structure of a short story. Never has she felt the need to write a full-length novel but none of the works she has in her repertoire necessarily need it. The comparison of Munro's "The Bear Came Over the Mountain" and Sarah Polley's film adaptation gives us a greater understanding of the influence short stories have within film. There is also the challenge of how directors must expand or limit specifics of the story due to the translation from the written to visual. This translation affects the story in multiple aspects, more particularly with how faithful Polley attempts to remain to the original story; …show more content…

This relationship is altered in Polley's film as a way to draw in audiences and allow for the romantic relationship that Hollywood cinema is notorious for. She establishes that there are two narrative structures within the film, a love story and a discovery story. The one that is most evident in the film is the love story, where Polley places emphasis on the lifestyle that Grant and Fiona have built around one another. This is seen in the opening sequence of the couple cross-country skiing, which would establish how their relationship would play out within the film. They begin to ski in tandem with each other, then separate, and later come back together. By incorporating this scene open the film, it is unconsciously planting in the audience the trajectory of the film: unity, separation and back to unity. In the film, they are seen together living their usual lives amidst their cabin happy. Then when Fiona's condition appears to be worsening, we see how their separation begins as Grant takes her to Meadowlake. This separation continues on when Aubrey becomes Fiona's center of attention, leaving Grant to feel cheated, ironically. The couple's unity is only evident in the final scene between the two when she embraces him. "You could have just driven away," she said. "Just driven away without a care in the world and forsook me. Forsooken me. Forsaken" … "He said, "Not a chance". This final interaction allows for the conclusion that Grant may never be able to just leave his wife alone at Meadowlake, but could allow her to lead another life from their own. Maintaining this theme of coming together or closure throughout the film is how Polley also allows for this other narrative to play out; Grant's narrative of

More about Comparison Of Alice Munro's The Bear Came Over The Mountain

Open Document