Comparing 'The New Colossus And America' By Claude Mckay

1531 Words4 Pages

“America” by Claude McKay is a poem dealing with McKay’s thoughts as he processes through his inner turmoil as he faces the reality of being rejected from a country that he loves. As Claude unveils his feelings to the reader, a creative description of America is presented. The poem deals with love and loyalty and the vicious rejection when you aren’t accepted in a society’s culture. In the short poem “The New Colossus” by Emma Lazarus showcases and contrasts the ancient Greek statue Helios and the Statue of liberty. Lazarus lets the reader compare the ancient Colossus of Rhodes, representing traditional masculinity in contrast with the New Colossus a feminine symbol of unity and refuge for those in need. Both poems are social commentaries …show more content…

Using the title is the beginning of the comparison Lazarus makes between the Old Colossus and the New Colossus. The old colossus is referring to the ancient statue of the Greek god Helios; the New Colossus was a woman the Statue of liberty. The narrator of the poem presumably, Lazarus is comparing the two statues to each other stating “Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame…A mighty woman with a torch… her name Mother of Exiles.” Lazarus continues the comparison on the next lines describing the female statue as “welcome” which is in direct contrast to the Old Colossus is meant to show power and authority. In the next lines five and six, Lazarus renames the statue of liberty into “Mother of Liberty” which personifies the statue and gives personality to this static object. A Mother is nurturing and caring, Lazarus uses these ideals to represent the statue of liberty. The personified statue then shouts, talking about the over glorified history of Greek mythology and cities “Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!” Lazarus may be implying that the old traditions and ancient rituals in the past. Welcoming refuges this popular quote is inscribed on the actual statue as follows “Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!” The quote “Your huddled masses yearning to breathe” highlights a unique comparison to the poem “America” previously discussed in this paper. This final passage is embodies the sentiment of the entire poem and communicates, hospitality, empathy and helping your fellow man which are morals America claims to

Open Document