Comparing Prometheus Bound and Hesiod's Prometheus

3393 Words7 Pages

Prometheus Bound and Hesiod's Prometheus Prometheus Bound is quite different from other tragedies in that it is peopled entirely by gods. The play focuses on the story of Prometheus, and we have versions of this myth in Hesiod's famous works. There is reason to think that the author of Prometheus Bound was not only acquainted with Hesiod's version but actually drew on Hesiod directly in this play. This essay therefore aims to establish in what ways the author of Prometheus Bound seems to have drawn from Hesiod's version of myth, in what ways he has diverged from it, and what reasons he might have had for making these changes and innovations. This might therefore highlight any particular emphasis or purpose of Prometheus Bound and what its author might have been trying to get across. Though there is not space in this essay to discuss the problems of attributing this play, it must be recognised that this ambiguity of authorship and dating makes it even more difficult than usual to look at views and purposes behind the play. We don't have any exact dates for Hesiod, but it seems that his poetic activity dates from around the last third of the 8th century BC. We find his versions of the Prometheus myth in two of his works: the Theogony at lines 521-616, and the Works and Days, at lines 42-89. The Theogony in general discusses the origin and genealogies of the gods and the events that led to the establishment of Zeus as their king. The Works and Days is quite varied in content but overall could be described as giving advice for living a life of honest industry. In the Theogony the story of Prometheus comes as a narrative interlude and aims at explaining the origins of certain institutions ... ... middle of paper ... ...aces', CQ 8 (1989) 42-60 * Frazer, R. M. The Poems of Hesiod (University of Oklahoma Press, U. S. A., 1983) * Griffith, M. Aeschylus: Prometheus Bound (Cambridge, 1983) * Most, G.W., 'Hesiod's Myth of the Five (or Three or Four) Races', PCPS 43 (1997) 104-127 * Scully, J & Herington, C.J., Aeschylus: Prometheus Bound (Oxford University Press, New York 1975) * Solmsen, F. Hesiod and Aeschylus (Ithaca, New York, 1949) * Wender, D. Hesiod and Theognis (Harmondsworth, 1973) * West, M. L. Hesiod: Theogony and Works and Days (Oxford, 1988) * West, M.L., 'The Prometheus Trilogy', JHS 99 (1979) 130-48 * Vellacott, P. Aeschylus: Prometheus Bound, Supplicants, Seven against Thebes, The Persians (Harmondsworth, 1961) Endnotes 1. Herington (1986) p158-9 2. Solmsen (1949) p136 3. Solmsen (1949) p130 4. Solmsen (1949) p129

Show More
Related

  • Occurence at Owl Creek Bridge

    1112 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bierce broke this story down into three parts. The first part of the narrative creates an atmosphere with the setting at Owl Creek Bridge. Great detail is told here as to who is present at the scene, what is happening, what the scene looks like, etc. But the reader only receives ideas and thoughts from one person, Peyton Farquar. The first part as like the other two parts of this story is written very systematically and clear. Even with such a structured set up, the author still manages to put great anticipation and fearsome emotion into the near end of the first part of this story. At this point the author makes the reader think Peyton is devising a way to set his hands free from the rope thereby beginning his journey to escape home.

    Read More

  • An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge

    1135 Words  | 3 Pages

    An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge uses dramatic irony, imagery and time to piece this short story together in a compelling way that brings the readers through the text in a swift, but gentle movement. Bierce is also protesting the Civil War going on in the United States as futile and inhumane. He produces a timeless piece that can be related to present times and times to come. He maintains control throughout the entire work and uses the element of surprise to the benefit of his work. Bierce’s ability to create a dramatic, detailed story using imagery and irony to establish a vibrant mental image and produce the well-written short story of An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge.

    Read More

  • Sleep Imagery in The Oresteia

    703 Words  | 2 Pages

    Aeschylus. The Oresteia. Trans. Richmond Lattimore. Ed. David Grene and Richmond Lattimore. Chicago: University of Chicago Press 1953.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge

    2124 Words  | 5 Pages

    This further emphasizes the brutal reality and evil the war has brought about. This scene comes about as a Union soldier traps a Confederate scout and personally convicted Fahrquhar and sentenced him to hanging. the narrator’s capturer is viewed as inherently evil. The capturer, Peyton Fahrquhar, teases the man and talks to him before finally hanging him. The main character has an illusion of where he escapes, and eventually Peyton Fahrquhar is the one hanged under Owl Creek Bridge at the end of the story. The irony in the story is very well portrayed, for in the narrator’s illusion he sees his capturer hanged under the bridge instead of him. The irony of this situation intertwines with the symbolism of the bridge itself. The bridge represents death in this story, because of the fact the narrator is hanged there. He knows his death is inevitable, and welcomes it when he realizes he cannot escape, even in his illusion. Not only is the bridge symbolic for death, but it also is beneficial for the reader to picture the scene in which the story takes place. Bierce provides a vivid description of the bridge, with the deep blue river rushing beneath it, so that the reader may picture the narrator’s predicament and what he sees from his point of view. In his illusion, the narrator sees and explains his capturer being the one hanged, saying, “Peyton Fahrquhar was dead;

    Read More

  • Pandora In Hesiod's Theogony

    1330 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both the poems of Hesiod’s tell of the curse of Pandora and both have Prometheus as the main character. Prometheus in both is the cause of why Zeus inflicted

    Read More

  • An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge: Summary and Review

    695 Words  | 2 Pages

    Since the setting of this story took place in Alabama, we know that there was a great deal of animosity between the North and South. Peyton asked a soldier that approached him and his wife about news from the front while his wife ran to get him some water. The soldier told Peyton that someone could possibly set a fire under the bridge because of all the dried driftwood there and that the bridge was only guarded by one person. We know that this was an attempt by the union to eliminate a steadfast southern supporter because of the last line, "He was a Federal scout." (par.17) I find it very odd that the couple would be so eager to speak with this soldier u...

    Read More

  • Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

    1322 Words  | 3 Pages

    Shelly’s use of the Prometheus myth combines the two versions of the legend, Prometheus the “fire-stealer” and Prometheus the “life-giver”. According to the Ancient Greeks, in the first version of the myth, the Titan, Prometheus, in rebellion against Zeus, took fire from the sun and gave it to humankind to warm them and enable them to make tools and weapons, thereby allowing them to rise above other animals. Zeus was incensed by Prometheus’ disobedience, and as punishment, ordered Prometheus chained to a rock, where his liver was eaten by eagles each day and restored each night so that his torment could be prolonged for eternity.

    Read More

  • An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge Theme Essay

    784 Words  | 2 Pages

    “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” is written by Ambrose Bierce with a plot that has a very unique twist to it. The fictional story takes place during 1860’s during the Civil War. Farquhar the main character in the story was caught trying to destroy the bridge and is sentenced to death by being hanged. The story is very thrilling because of the amounts of flashbacks including the settings, Farquhar’s senses. An Occurrence of Owl Creek Bridge presents the readers with many themes throughout the fictional story. Reality and illusion is one of the themes, the theme shows us that the character is trying to make his main problem go away by making and thinking of a happier moment. Time is another theme this is showing us that the story

    Read More

  • The Importance In Hesiod's Theogony, The Muses?

    1228 Words  | 3 Pages

    That is not to be taken negative, nearly every influence was a positive one. The daughters of Zeus chose the author to be the bearer of the stories that follow the hymn at the beginning of Theogony merely by random, but some may argue that it was fate, referring back to the Muses’ all-knowingness. The Muses were very important to Hesiod because they influenced him to become a poet and to write about the origins of Greek gods. Having such a large impact on his life is the very reason that Hesiod wanted to emphasize his relationship with the Muses at the start of the poem. He made this inclusion of the Muses as a way of appreciation for their guidance. Hesiod also wanted to make this emphasis because he wanted the readers to be aware of where he gained all of this knowledge of the Greek gods. Informing the audience that his resource for the origins and stories of the gods were from the all-knowing daughters of Zeus, the Muses, would make the stories that the readers were able to explore more trustworthy. One could not simply deny the credibility of Hesiod’s poem if he was told firsthand by the Muses. Hesiod’s relationship with the Muses made his poem stand out as if he were there to witness the events himself. The relationship between Zeus’s daughters and the author is also further revealed when he

    Read More

  • Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge

    1226 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bierce is An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge Is an impeccable story that takes place during the civil war. The story is both mesmerizing and mysterious. It is based the execution of a Southern farmer and Confederate spy and slave owner named Peyton Farquhar, who dedicated his life to the “southern cause (p.317)”. After being tricked by another spy into trying to burn the bridge, Farquhar found himself in a place where no one could save him. He was caught by the union army for breaking the law. Farquhar was on the verge of being executed not by gun, but by one of the most tragic way; by hanging. As he was being executed, he fell into the illusion of escaping death in an accident but exhilarated

    Read More

  • Things Fall Apart

    984 Words  | 2 Pages

    Things Fall Apart is by the widely acclaimed African author Chinua Achebe. The story told is a tragic one of a person by the name of Okonkwo who's own stubborn views about what it is to be a man leads to his own demise. Okonkwo is often compared by people to the tragic hero like those in Greek tragedies. This is probably the primary way in which the text is interpreted but I feel Achebe is trying to make another point as well through the story. Achebe received inspiration to write the novel from a poem written by an Englishman by the name of William Butler Yeats. The title of the poem is The Second Coming. The poem talks about anarchy that is upon the world during the present time and how things will change with the 'second coming." During this 'second coming'; the chaos that is prevalent will end finally after two thousand years. Achebe uses this poems basic idea by creating the story of Okonkwo who lives in a chaotic and barbaric world. To outsiders who are observing Okonkwo's people, they may certainly seem uncivilized in many ways. Achebe symbolizes the end of this anarchy in Okonkwo's society by the introduction of Christian missionaries who pacify the Ibo people and ultimately cause the death of Okonkwo. I believe Okonkwo is the last and final source of chaos that is finally muted to bring civility to the people.

    Read More

  • Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge Mood

    1253 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the short story “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” Bierce theme is that life is not always a fairytale. Real life is sometimes interrupted by tragedy and does not always have a happy ending. Bierce’s sarcastic tone gives off the idea that he is making fun of fairytail dreams. “Their movements were grotesque and horrible, their forms gigantic”(486), describing the soldiers setting up to shoot at Peyton and emphasizing the hard truth about war. It is grotesque and horrible. People kill and people die, but then each and every bullet just perfectly misses Peyton while he maneuvered his way through the water. This created an illusion of almost impossible superhero-like qualities that Peyton seemed to have, but this was imagined. This dream-like state foreshadowed that it was not real and was more of a fairytale. This contrast between reality and fairytale is what makes the theme so vivid at the end of the

    Read More

  • Love and Duty in Virgil’s Aeneid and Augustine’s Confessions

    1593 Words  | 4 Pages

    Virgil. “The Aeneid, Book IV”. The Norton Anthology of Western Literature. 8th ed. Vol. 1. New York: W.W. Norton, 2006. 974-95. Print.

    Read More

  • Things Fall Apart by Chinua Achebe

    1111 Words  | 3 Pages

    Okonkwo crumbled under the newly developed society of the white man in Umofia. He could no longer act on his fury, vehemence or impetuousness, because acting in those non-compliant ways got him no further advancement and was frowned upon. Okonkwo lost his mental composure and everything in his life went to pieces because of it. His lack of sensitivity and understanding of those different from him handicapped his entire life. Okonkwo’s strength was further proven to have many fallacies because he was not strong in the important aspects of having composure and not acting on impulse. He could no longer control the people around him, nor his own life so he became misfortune of a classic tragedy.

    Read More

  • Analog Devices, Inc.

    1065 Words  | 3 Pages

    (4) Differences between the half-life concept and the experience curve concept: the experience curve, like the half-life, is also an empirical observation. It states that for each doubling of cumulative experience, real unit cost drops by a constant percentage. Half-life deals with defects, not cost. The half-life method, on the other hand, predicts that the rate of decline of defect level is constant over time. The experience curve is a purely empirical observation and is not based on any underlying theory. On the other hand, there is a theoretical basis for the half-life model.

    Read More

More about Comparing Prometheus Bound and Hesiod's Prometheus

Open Document