Comparing Atkins and Balance Energy Bars

444 Words1 Page

Comparing Atkins and Balance Energy Bars

Many are fascinated by the various diets in society; people want

to lose weight by finding a reliable method that will ensure results.

Two common diets include the Atkins Diet and the Zone Diet. Both of

these have energy bars that contain the nutrients need to meet the diets

specific requirements. In the article “Glycemic and Insulinemic

responses to energy bars of differing macronutrient composition in

healthy adults,” by Steven Hetzler and Veonsoo Kim, a study was conducted

that compared the different energy bars. The study looked at equal

proportions of these bars to see their effects on glycemic and

insulinemic levels. This paper will be focusing on the differences

between the Atkins and Balance Energy Bars and the effect they have on

glycemic and insulin.

The Atkins Diet contains a low amount of carbohydrates, whereas

the Zone Diet has the components of a 40% carbohydrate, 30% protein, and

30% fat breakdown. The energy bars associated with these diet influences

the glycemic and insulin levels in the body. By having a reduction of

glycemic and insulin levels in the body affects a diet. By having low

glucose levels this will ultimately lead to weight loss. This happens

either through the removal of carbohydrates or by substituting low

glycemic index carbohydrates for higher ones. In doing this the higher

level of insulin will be reduced, for example high blood cholesterol

levels will go down.

To test the insulin and glycemic levels the energy bars contain

the study had 20 healthy adult participants. They were split into groups

receiving 1 of 5 test meals; 1 being low carbohydrates, 2) moderate

carbohydrates, 3) high carbohydrates, 4) white bread, and 5) chicken

breast. Chicken breast was the negative control since it contains no

carbohydrates, whereas white bread was the positive control. Test meals

1) with the low carbohydrates, include the Atkins Energy Bar, and test

meal 2) includes the Balance Energy Bar.

In order to see the levels of the glucose and insulin after

consuming the bars blood samples were taken and analyzed. In this

experiment the Atkins energy bar produced the lowest glucose results.

Open Document