Compare/Contrast Paper

1154 Words3 Pages

In Jo Ann Beard’s “The Fourth State of Matter” and Jay McInerey’s “It’s Six A.M. Do You Know Where You Are?”, two completely different main characters find themselves recently separated from their spouse and alone. Throughout both of these stories, we see the struggles that these individuals face as they cope with their grief after separating from their significant other and accepting their new realities. The narrator in “The Fourth State of Matter” consumes her time in caring for her ailing dog and working as a physics magazine editor; the main character in “It’s Six A.M. Do You Know Where You Are?” spends his time abusing cocaine and looking for another companion. While the two characters handle their situation in two completely different ways, they do, however, possess some similar qualities. Ultimately, they have both come to find themselves in a reality that is stuck between the past and the future. In the end, both characters are able to accept their divorces probably because they have felt so lonely for far too long; they can finally move on with their lives. “The Fourth State of Matter” and “It’s Six A.M. Do You Know Where You Are?” both depict how misfortune can leave the characters in each story in inertia between reminiscing on the past and moving forward into the future and how difficult moving on can actually be for these characters who fear the feeling of being abandonment so much.
In “The Fourth State of Matter”, the narrator is suspended in her own grief after her recent separation from her husband followed by yet another unexpected tragic event. In the beginning of the narrative, she refers to her spouse as “the husband”, refraining from calling him by his actual name. The narrator probably does this because she ...

... middle of paper ...

...being lonely for the rest of his life. He was now finally figured out on his own that being single forever is not necessarily his fate.
Throughout both of these stories, we see the struggle that these two characters face as they each learn to manage their emotions after being separated from their spouses. While it may have initially seemed as though they were leading two completely different lives, they are actually leading two very similar lives all at once. Whether it is constantly cleaning up after a sick dog or searching for women at the bar after getting high, by the conclusion of each story, these characters have ultimately grown to accept their new, “wedged” lives as they are. They have feared the feeling of abandonment for so long that they have essentially forced themselves to move on rather than remaining stuck in this limbo they have found themselves in.

Open Document