Compare And Contrast Winnie The Pooh

948 Words2 Pages

Walt Disney produced a book, Winnie-the-Pooh, based on the movie “The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh.” Because Disney normally does a fantastic job at turning its movies into children’s books I expected Winnie-the-Pooh be executed at the same level of excellence. However, this was not the case; I found Winnie-the-Pooh’s two major handicaps to be its illustrations and absurd length.
Many storylines intertwine with each other throughout the piece. Unlike the effortless progression of the plots in “The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh,” when the same progression is presented in Winnie-the-Pooh the storyline begins to seem uncoordinated. At the beginning of the book and movie, Pooh wakes up hungry for honey. In both of them, Pooh tries to …show more content…

In the movie, you can see Rabbit get annoyed and try to avoid Pooh bear. While the written word of the book tells the readers that Rabbit is trying to avoid Pooh, Rabbit being startled is the only expression shown by the illustrations. Rabbit was trying to avoid Pooh Rabbit tried to avoid Pooh because he knew the bear would eat all of his honey. In the book, only three empty honey jars are shown; while the movie shows Rabbit’s house is covered with empty honey jars. The significant difference in the number of empty jars would better show kids just how hungry Pooh bear is. Some people may argue that leaving Rabbit being annoyed out of the book is best for little kids. Parents could say that leaving out this negative behavior would be beneficial for their children because they are at an impressionable age. However, I would argue that by leaving out Rabbit’s obvious annoyance would be completely changing the identity of Disney’s character. Therefore, when the children are not able to see Rabbit’s progress in becoming a better friend. This growth is important because it teaches children the value of friendship and forgiveness. This section of the movie humorously ends with Pooh finally getting his honey from the tree, and once again, the book does not relay the humor seen in the …show more content…

“The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh” is only an hour and fourteen minutes long. This is the perfect screen time for a young child. The major drawback of the length of the book is how wordy the book is. A kid as young as five does not want to read paragraphs; they would prefer a book where the pictures tell most of the story.
The length of Winnie-the-Pooh would be more bearable for young readers if there were not as many words in the story. When children are just beginning to read, they cannot read themselves an entire book. During this age group, parents read books to their children. With the excessive wording see in the book, parents get tired of reading it after a short amount of time. When the parents get annoyed with the book, it shows in their voice. However, the child assumes the annoyance is with them, not the book. This miscommunication can put a strain on the parent-child

Open Document