Compare And Contrast Two Short Story

1293 Words3 Pages

Similarities and Differences While studying short stories brought forward are both many similarities and many differences, which you may not see by just, reading one. Within three short stories, “Up in Michigan” by Ernest Hemingway, “Happy Endings” by Margaret Atwood, and “The Cask of Amontillado” by Edgar Allan Poe there are many similarities along with many differences. From similarities such as genre, climax, and style to differences such as point of view, theme, and plot these three stories portray short stories in an excellent way.
One similarity is that they are all classified as Fiction in which means that they are imaginary events and people, although the stories many sound true and real they are not which portrays the story as …show more content…

Within both stories, “Up in Michigan” and “Happy Endings” they share the same theme, love, although they are both portrayed in different ways. In “Up in Michigan” Ernest Hemingway portrays it in her thoughts, he does make it known within the story there is a love interest from Liz to Jim, although Jim shows no special interest to Liz, but it is exclusively in Liz’s thoughts. In “Happy Endings” Margaret Atwood expresses the love theme in almost a comical way. Although she writes in many different sub stories, within each story there is a love story portrayed in a different way with the same result. Atwood has a very truthful way of expressing the love interest in the stories. Mary falls in love with whomever it is that she falls in love with within the story, very straightforward. “The Cask of Amontillado” on the other hand has a very different theme then the other two stories. Edgar Allan Poe focuses on the theme revenge throughout the story as a whole. He makes it very clear in the beginning that he promised himself that he would seek revenge on Fortunato and throughout the story you watch as Montresor seeks that revenge and the ways in which he does

Open Document