Classical Theory of Justice

The Classical Theory of Justice is definitely a complex issue to ponder. Although its definitive words seem simple, such as, “one good deed deserves another,” or “justice consists in rendering to each his due,” the interpretation of such justices is not clear. Because there is no such thing as a black and white system or world, I cannot simply say that all people will receive what is due to them. In fact, life appears to be much more of a gamble than a certainty. Example, ten people who reside in ten different locations could all perform a noble act. However, what if only one of the ten receives recognition for their noble acts, and is it unjust that the other nine do not receive equal recognition. Surely all ten were excellent in their actions. However, I do agree that it is natural to most that we should desire to reward a noble act and punish an evil one. Yet, it is important to remember that society does not give equal rewards to all people all of the time. There is no possible way to keep track diligently of every good or bad act and consistently reward or punish equivalently.

Therefore, as I do agree that it seems universal to most individuals that good begets good and bad does earn punishment. The natural reaction of most people will fall in that order. However, I would like to point attention to that fact that historically it is obvious that people focus on wrong doings. For instance, the Ten Commandments and the bible focus on wrong actions. The major message being that man is inherently evil. A great deal of effort and focus is directed at convincing man to behave. Then as individuals fulfill this requirement, they are rewarded. It makes you wonder if the expectations and the realm of scrutiny inspire good acts, and ...

... middle of paper ...

...I believe that regardless of what you inherit that you are in charge of yourself. With the exception of the cognitively challenged, it is fair to expect individuals to make life choices. With or without recognizing social or environmental contributions, it is a choice that each person makes each day as to how they will behave. Because modern society has chosen to reward “good” acts and punish “bad” acts, the majority of the population follows suit. I think that it is feasible that people are conditioned to a belief system, but this does not make the system correct. Much of the laws today are based on social norms, which fluctuate over time. Things or actions that were once legal are now deemed illegal and vice versa. The theories continue to fluctuate with cultural changes. I do not believe there is one theory of justice nor there ever one. Justice is subjective.