Castration Of Sex Offenders Article Analysis

1317 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Literature review about effectiveness of treatment strategies for sex offenders

In the article, there are two authors with different views, one saying serious sex offenders should be castrated and the other saying that it shouldn’t be allowed. The author that is for the castration of sex offenders is Lawrence Wright, an Attorney from the state of Texas. Lawrence Wright talks about the controversy over castrating sex offenders as well as the role society has on either allowing or not allowing these castrations to happen. Wright argues that even though castration might not end up being the ideal choice, if instead we the people treat it as a form of therapy and not punishment and treat these offenders as victims not monsters, then maybe one day this will allow castration to be a viable sex offender treatment. He also went on to say that we should help these offenders instead of seeking revenge on them.On the other hand, another Attorney Kari A. Vanderzyl believes that castration of sex offenders should not be allowed. Her main argument is that the castration of sex offenders is not unacceptable and for the most part ineffective, but also it is just an alternative to imprisonment for these offenders. Vanderzyl views this alternative not just only as unconstitutional, but also a violation of many of our amendment rights as well.
2. What evidence supports the author’s thesis?
In order to state why castrations should be allowed on sex offenders, Wright provides key information and examples as to why it should be allowed. He first talks a little bit about the sex offenders they currently have in jail in Texas. He explains that only a small amount are actually receiving therapy and how more than half will be arrested for a sex crime a few years later after getting released from jail. The next thing Wright talks abou...

... middle of paper ...

...nt that could go against her is that if you are not for the castration of sex offenders, then what treatment will be given in order to help these offenders? The current treatment that is given to offenders in jail according to Lawrence Wright, is not working as it is often only for short periods of time as well as only given to the ones who need it the least. Currently, castration is the only method that actually shows any significant changes in sex offenders, where it effects them behaviorally. This creates the argument that Vanderzyl would have to answer, would you rather stick with the procedures in place that are ineffective or allow castrations as alternate? Even if she’s still skeptical, there can be tests done where sex offenders have the procedure done and if the results are positive and help offenders then good, if not she can still side with her argument.

Show More
Related

  • Sex Offender Registration And Notification In Texas Case Study

    1028 Words  | 3 Pages

    The following research will display an overview of the process in Texas on how sex offenders are registered along with the notifications that are followed after registration. Texas, as many other states, has a procedure which requires sex offenders to register with the local law enforcement agencies at the time of their discharge. In addition to registration, they must also comply with further probation regulations. Research has concluded that there are four basic phases of registration and notification. Beginning with offender notified, following the offender registration and community notified and ending with public notification

    Read More

  • The Rise of America’s Prison Empire

    1930 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the event that a prisoner (particularly a sex offender) does complete rehabilitation, he carries with him a stigma upon reentering society. People often fear living near a prior drug addict or convicted murderer and the sensational media hype surrounding released felons can ruin a newly released convict’s life before it beings. What with resident notifications, media scare tactics and general concern for safety, a sex offender’s ability to readapt into society is severely hindered (554). This warrants life-skills rehabilitation applied to him useless, as he will be unable to even attempt to make the right decision regarding further crime opportunities.

    Read More

  • The Impact of Megan's Law

    2818 Words  | 6 Pages

    ...aker, J. (2007). Public perceptions about sex offenders and community protection policies. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, 7(1), 1-25.

    Read More

  • The Root Causes of Sexual Offending: Social Learning Theory

    1310 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many resources go into the prevention and management of sex offenders. However, very few effective programs exist that decrease the likelihood of reoffending. Through the use of meta-analyses, Seto and Lalumiere (2010) evaluated multiple studies that examined sex offenders. Emphasis was put on etiological explanations in the hopes of identifying factors associated with sex offending. Seto and Lalumiere’s (2010) findings help in creating effective programs to decrease recidivism rates.

    Read More

  • Sexual Offender Laws and the Labeling Theory

    1393 Words  | 3 Pages

    This essay will discuss the many different types of sex offenses that are considering a crime. It will then talk about some of the historical sexual offenders laws that have shaped society as a whole. It will also define the role religion plays on the emergence of new Sex offender’s laws that we have in contemporary societies. And finally talk about the emergence of some currents sex offenses laws we have in our nation.

    Read More

  • Female Sex Offenders: Perception is Not Reality

    1632 Words  | 4 Pages

    The acceptance that the court system often treats female offenders differently than male offenders is an accurate statement; however, it comes with many caveats. Generally, the public views women as nurturers, motherly and incapable of harming a child. Research indicates that female sex offenders capable of committing such acts have serious psychiatric and psychological problems. In comparison, research indicates male sex offenders are more callous, more antisocial, and promiscuous, involved in the criminal justice system, and have more victims (Miccio-Fenseca, 2012, slide 7). The consensus is that men commit their acts for sexual pleasure while women commit their acts due to psychiatric and psychological problems. Law enforcement, juries, and judges tend to empathize more when there are additional mitigating factors such as emotional or psychological problems. Due to these mitigating factors, it appears treatment of female sex offenders is more lenient than male if their crimes are similar in nature. Research by Miccio-Fenseca (2012) indicates that in comparison to their male counterparts, “female sex offenders rarely use force or violence far less than often…rarely use threats of violence to silence victims…rarely use threats o...

    Read More

  • Sex Offender Registry Essay

    1390 Words  | 3 Pages

    Rehabilitate, and develop, both of the utmost substance when observing the ways in which a sex offender registry are and

    Read More

  • Background of Sex Offender Registries

    2351 Words  | 5 Pages

    Sex offender legislation has become a controversial topic in the recent years. There have been numerous laws enacted in response to sex offender crime. Do these laws really work to help minimize re-offending, or do they give the public a false sense of security and cause recidivism? In a several studies researchers found no evidence of sex offender registries being effective in increasing public safety. Some studies have found that requiring sex offenders to register with law enforcement may significantly may reduce chances of recidivism. However, the research also found that making registry information available to the public may back fire and lead to higher levels of overall sex crimes

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Sex Offenders

    1497 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sex offenders. These people have sparked much debate in the years past and also quite a lot now in the present time. No matter where one could go, one will always hear stories and news reports of incidents of adults being involved with children in a sexual manner or of some poor woman being raped. An example of this could be a preacher touching the altar boys, a man forcing himself onto a woman he held at gun point in an alley, it may just be an average run of the mill creep offering kids candy at a playground hoping to get something in return, or unfortunately it could just be a drunk person seen urinating outside, but that is the day and age we live in. The list is endless unfortunately and these offenders some in a variety of shapes, sizes, and appearances. There are a number of various factors such as what a sex offender is, what drives them, what civil commitment is, how civil commitment can be a solution, and why it might not work. First the question must be asked, what is a sex offender?

    Read More

  • Sex Offenders Essay

    1241 Words  | 3 Pages

    Although they may be out of jail, they cannot be considered free. They are unable to make their own decisions: where they can work, where they can live, and how they can live their lives are all under control of the government. These people look the same as everyone else, but underneath the mask, lay a title they cannot shake. These people are sex offenders. A sex offender is defined as anyone who has committed a sexual crime. These crimes range from serious crimes, like rape, to minor offenses, such as urinating in public, or under age consensual sex. All sex offenders are placed on the registry and are required to follow a careful protocol. Registered sex offenders are paired with a Community Corrections Officer (CCO) who oversees and supervises the offender's actions. Many restrictions are placed on the offender, and although the laws can vary from state to state, there are some basic restrictions that apply to every offender. Some of these restrictions include: a sex offender cannot move without the permission and approval of their CCO, they can only live and work in certain areas, they cannot own any firearms, their personal computers are monitored and controlled by their CCO (many websites are blocked, including pornographic content), they are not allowed to take or consume any mind altering substances such as drugs or even alcohol, and they are required to get regular counseling (“Rules”). Currently there are 747,408 registered sex offenders in the United States. Some states such as Delaware and Oregon have a higher concentration of sex offenders (500 per 100,000) where as Pennsylvania has the lowest concentration of sex offenders (94 per 100,000) (“Sex Offender Statistics”). Due to the inefficiencies ...

    Read More

  • Essay On Sex Offenders Rehabilitation

    932 Words  | 2 Pages

    Sexual offenders are typically looked upon as being one of the most common of offenders to relapse. That being said, the best way is to have a proper treatment plan in place for them to abide by so that they do have the urge or desire to participate in previous activities that would otherwise land them back in jail. When treated in cognitive-behavioral environments, rehabilitation for the offender is said to be the most effective. Through a proper behavioral environment, training offenders with separate approaches and managing treatments regularly, sexual offenders do stand a chance of becoming a productive member of society without recidivism to old habits.

    Read More

  • Sex Offender Registry Essay

    845 Words  | 2 Pages

    "US: Sex Offender Laws May Do More Harm Than Good." http://www.hrw.org. 2014, Human Rights Watch, 11 September 2007. Web. 13 Feb 2014. <

    Read More

  • Canada Should Focus More on Rehabilitation and Less on Retribution

    3232 Words  | 7 Pages

    Yates, P. M. (2005). Pathways to treatment of sexual offenders: Rethinking intervention. Forum on Corrections Research, 17, 1-9.

    Read More

  • Recidivism of Sex Offenders

    2497 Words  | 5 Pages

    problem for the public, as potential victims, and the legal system which is entrusted by the public for protection. It would be irresponsible for the legal system to ignore the criminal class of sex offenders, for they are subject to a recurring physiological urge that requires the use of effective restraints that would curb the habitual repetition of episodes producing the harmful consequences to the public(Schopf 95). In light of this realization, steps beyond treatment have been taken to reduce the recidivism rate of sex offenders. Notification laws, special supervising techniques by parole officers, and both surgical and chemical castration are techniques used in various forms in this country and abroad with success. However, notification laws and both forms of castrations

    Read More

  • The Problems with Our Justice System

    536 Words  | 2 Pages

    Second time offenders of sex crimes such as rape should be castrated and emasculated slowly with a dull, rusty knife. The criminal should be revived every time he passes out from pain. This heinous crime deserves this much at the very least. After all, this person has violated another person and taken something away, a trust that can never be fully restored. The victims of these crimes never fully trust again.

    Read More

More about Castration Of Sex Offenders Article Analysis

Open Document