Case Study On Ethical Dilemmas

1041 Words3 Pages

How many of us can agree on being in a situation, specifically within a group, when we had to choose between voicing our beliefs or losing respect over our beliefs to “go along” with the crowd by being told you had to sign something or become derecognized? Well, Tina, a volunteer leader of InterVarsity Christian Fellowship, is soon to be hit with a religious dilemma in respect to a policy that is forced to be signed for nondiscriminatory purposes. Facing ethical dilemmas is very common in the world and we have to learn to deal with them on a daily basis. In this paper, the case study being presented with reflect on the ethical dilemma through core beliefs, possible resolutions, evaluations, and comparisons being made from a Christian worldview …show more content…

Although Tina really wants to be part of a recognized group because of the importance of it and the benefits, it may mean going against her Christian beliefs in some way and this becomes a dilemma for her. To resolve this dilemma, Tina could do one of the following:
• Emphasize her Christian beliefs, in hopes of making a change,
• Emphasize her Christian beliefs, lose recognition that she really wants, and possibly lose her membership privileges, or
• Be a team player in agreement with the policy and still have the benefits she desires, but the feeling of Christian beliefs being overlooked.
Core Beliefs
One of the core beliefs is the First Amendment that states the freedom of exercising religion, freedom of speech, and freedom of press. “Freedom of religion is one of the key civil rights enshrined within the First Amendment” (Hawley & Taylor, 2003). Tina and the Christian Fellowship has a right to their freedom of religion, but it is also important to make sure such freedom expression does not cause confrontation. Freedom of religion gives everyone the right to express their …show more content…

The reason being is because there will be many obstacles for her to cross on differentiating opinions and worldviews. To overcome such dilemmas in the near future, being able to accept this new policy will get her recognition and satisfaction of doing the right thing. Tina is “called to help people learn to do everything Jesus said” (Pasley, 2014). By agreeing to the nondiscrimination policy, Tina is showing that she accept and respect that others’ may be different and this gives her a chance to grow. According to the lecture, “purposeful living leads to ethical living” (“Lecture 7,” 2015). This ethical dilemma may have been presented to Tina to help her find her purpose in life; therefore, now she can have an ethical living in respect to other

Open Document