Book Review of "The Return of Martin Guerre"

817 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Life of french peasants 18th century

In The Return of Martin Guerre, one man's impersonation of an heir from an influential peasant family in the French village of Artigat ultimately leads to his public execution. The tale of Arnaud du Tilh alias Pansette (meaning "the belly") is full of ironies, not the least of which is his death at the hands of a man who by some accounts harbored some admiration for the quick-witted peasant. Set in a time and place where a hardly discernible line separated proper behavior from that which was grounds for death, du Tilh was guilty of more than one serious charge. Yet he was well-known as a strong farmer, loving husband, shrewd rural-merchant, and eloquent speaker. Arnaud's actions are not the result of his own audacity, rather of something more universal, so universal its results can be seen in other historical figures from the text. Du Tilh assumed Martin Guerre's identity because doing so represented a unique opportunity to test the extent of his abilities and leave behind his presently troubled life.

Everyone has an inborn mechanism that once in a while tells us, "You need a vacation." This couldn't have been truer than for someone like Arnaud du Tilh. Davis writes, "Arnaud du Tilh became known as `dissolute,' a youth of `bad life,' `absorbed in every vice.'" His mix of tomfoolery and heightened intelligence made him stand out. "So clever was Pansette that he began to be suspected of magic." Manipulating "evil spirits" was a serious charge in the 16th century. As an escape Pansette left to fight for Henri II in Picardy. Here he seems to be searching for an escape from his life, a sort of permanent vacation. So it happens that as Arnaud is traveling along the Salat River, he happens upon two of Martin Guerre's old frien...

... middle of paper ...

... of Spain." Arnaud was able to satisfy his thirst for mischief while at the same time helping to establish a respected family. By doing so he created a rift in the entire village of Artigat, while abandoning his own family.

The search to define ones self is continuous, and ends only in death. Arnaud du Tilh had found a home, and was content. During the trials, he wasn't merely arguing for his life, he wanted to keep the life he once had with Bertrande and his daughters. Du Tilh did not plan to take their inheritance for himself, upon examining excerpts from the book; we see that he was establishing a profitable business for his new family. No matter his true motive the place and times conspired against him, and he ended no better than the man whose identity he sought to steal.

Davis, Natalie. The Return of Martin Guerre. Boston: Harvard Press. 1983. P. 37

Show More
Related

  • The Return of Martin Guerre by Natalie Davis

    1452 Words  | 3 Pages

    The main focus of the story is on Bertrande de Rols and her place in sixteenth century society, especially as a wife. At the age of nine, Bertrande was married to Martin Guerre who was a young peasant of Basque heritage. For several years, the two have trouble consummating their marriage. In 1548, Martin runs away from his village of Artigat, France to join the Spanish army, leaving his twenty-two year old wife Bertrande and a young son. After eight years of living in quiet desperation, an imposter Arnaud du Tilh nicknamed "Pansette," shows up in the village in 1548, in the guise of Martin Guerre. It is no wonder that Bertrande would finally find fulfillment of her hopes and dreams of a better life with the new Martin. The couple's marital bliss unravels the day Arnaud argues with his uncle, Pierre Guerre, over his desire to sell off some of his ancestral land. Under Basque tradition and custom, a man is never to sell his ancestral land this causes Pierre to be suspicious of the identity of his nephew and he decides to sue Arnaud as an imposter.

    Read More

  • Book Review of William Prochnau's, Once upon a Distant War

    466 Words  | 1 Pages

    Beginning in the early 1960's American journalists began taking a hard look at America's involvement in South Vietnam. This inevitably led to a conflict with the American and South Vietnamese governments, some fellow journalists, and their parent news organizations. This was the last hurrah of print journalism, as television began to grow in stature. William Prochnau's, Once Upon A Distant War, carefully details the struggles of these hardy journalists, led by David Halberstram, Malcolm Browne, and Neil Sheehan. The book contains stories, told in layers, chronicling America's growing involvement in South Vietnam from 1961 through 1963.

    Read More

  • Peasant Lifestyle In Davis´ The Return of Martin Guerre

    1599 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Return of Martin Guerre, written by Natalie Zemon Davis, is the tale of a court case that takes place in sixteenth century France. Martin Guerre is a peasant who deserted his wife and family for many years. While Martin Guerre is gone, a man named Arnaud du Tilh arrives at Martin’s village and claims to be Martin Guerre. Bertrande, who is Guerre’s wife, Guerre’s sisters, and many of the villagers, accepts the imposter. After almost three years of being happily married, Bertrande takes the fraud to court under pressure of Pierre Guerre, her stepfather and Guerre’s brother. Arnaud du Tilh is almost declared innocent, but the real Martin Guerre appears in the courthouse. Throughout this tale, many factors of the peasant life are highlighted. The author gives a very effective and detailed insight to a peasant’s life during the time of Martin Guerre. Davis does a successful job of portraying the peasant lifestyle in sixteenth century France by accentuating the social, cultural, and judicial factors of everyday peasant life.

    Read More

  • Mark Danner's The Massacre at El Mozote

    1433 Words  | 3 Pages

    Mark Danner, an editor for the New York Times magazine, recounts in The Massacre at El Mozote a horrific crime against humanity committed by a branch of the Salvadorian army. He gives multiple points of views and cites numerous eye witnesses to try and piece together something that has been tucked away by the government at the time. In December, of 1981, news reports were leaked to major newspapers in the united states about an atrocity committed and a total massacre of a hamlet in El Salvador, known as El Mozote, or the Thicket. At first, the account was of over a thousand civilians, women men and children with no guerrilla affiliation were massacred. Danner pieces together the testimonies of the survivors, and interviews with officers in the Salvadorian army.

    Read More

  • Comparing Chocolat And Vianne's Chocolate

    1168 Words  | 3 Pages

    seems to find, but is always longing for. While on the other hand, Comte de Reynaud is a mayor

    Read More

  • Bertrande de Rols Analysis

    1029 Words  | 3 Pages

    After years of abandonment, an absent man presumed to be Martin Guerre appeared in front of a woman who longed for a strong love and different husband. An “obstinate and honorable” woman could no...

    Read More

  • Essay on Camus’ The Stranger (The Outsider): Parallels Within

    945 Words  | 2 Pages

    Meursault is a fairly average individual who is distinctive more in his apathy and passive pessimism than in anything else. He rarely talks because he generally has nothing to say, and he does what is requested of him because he feels that resisting commands is more of a bother than it is worth. Meursault never did anything notable or distinctive in his life: a fact which makes the events of the book all the more intriguing.

    Read More

  • Without Pain There is No Happiness in A Rumor of War by Phillip Caputo

    822 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are many elements use to describe pain and suffering during novels such as, A Rumor of War and the other works that represent war and the other topics within war. Without this common element within these books and other works, war would not be accurately represented.

    Read More

  • The Wars by Timothy Findley

    726 Words  | 2 Pages

    Many people say that the metal of a man is found in his ability to keep his ideals in spite of anything that life can through at you. If a man is found to have done these things he can be called a hero. Through a lifelong need to accept responsibility for all living things, Robert Ross defines his heroism by keeping faith with his ideals despite the betrayal, despair and tragedy he suffers throughout the course of The Wars by Timothy Findley.

    Read More

  • Narcissism In 'Cask Of Amontillado'

    1084 Words  | 3 Pages

    Thinking too much of oneself can blind a person of their wrongdoings until it is too late. For instance, Armand found out after the departure of his wife and son that it was he that was not white while purging all things that reminded Armand of his family, “…Armand will never know that his mother… belongs to the race that is cursed with the brand of slavery” he reads from a stray letter found in his dresser from his mom to his father (Chopin). Fortunato was lustful to death for Amontillado, despite the series of warnings concerning his health. For prime example, “In an instant he had reached the extremity of the niche, and finding his progress arrested by the rock, stood stupidly bewildered” although Montresor guided him it was his greed that steered him to his demise (Poe). Both characters faced the harsh reality that their narcissistic ways ultimately ended with the presence of

    Read More

  • A Rumor Of War By Philip Caputo

    1199 Words  | 3 Pages

    A Rumor of War is a book written by Philip Caputo on his experience in Vietnam and the hardships of being in war. His journey began at the age of 24 when he is diploid, from 1960 until 1965. The book illustrates this image of Caputo of the maturity process he goes through. Caputo explains his main reason for going to war was his experience during the Camelot of the Kennedy era, where like many other Americans, Caputo wanted to know "what he could do for his country," as according to what President Kennedy said in his speech. Many Americans at the time believed that they needed to have that spirit and embrace their country. The images portrayed by the media impacted how Americans responded to the heroism these soldiers accomplished. Caputos accomplishments with the war was completely parallel to those of the American people.

    Read More

  • Sacrifice in A Tale of Two Cities

    1033 Words  | 3 Pages

    Dr. Manette is imprisoned in the French Bastille for eighteen years by the cruel French government and unknown to him those many years of pain and suffering serve as a great sacrifice in the eyes of the Revolutionists. He is recalled to life from the time he served when he meets Lu...

    Read More

  • Pacifism And Colonialism In The War By Louis-Ferdinand Céline

    1539 Words  | 4 Pages

    As a young man, Louis-Ferdinand Céline signs up for the cavalry during World War I. The atrocities that he witnesses during his time here shape the way he sees the world for the rest of his life. His experiences in the war draw him to pacifism and nihilism. Drawn by heroism and nationalism, the young Céline finds only pointlessness and waste of human life. After the war, in which he approves of cowardice, Céline sets sail to Africa to work in the French colony of Cameroon. In this colony there is extreme white supremacy, while the indigenous population is suppressed. The white colonists act and are treated as gods. During this period Céline starts to question morality of humanity.

    Read More

  • Timothy Findley's The Wars

    1719 Words  | 4 Pages

    War has been a constant part of human history. It has greatly affected the lives of people around the world. These effects, however, are extremely detrimental. Soldiers must shoulder extreme stress on the battlefield. Those that cannot mentally overcome these challenges may develop Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Sadly, some resort to suicide to escape their insecurities. Soldiers, however, are not the only ones affected by wars; family members also experience mental hardships when their loved ones are sent to war. Timothy Findley accurately portrays the detrimental effects wars have on individuals in his masterpiece The Wars.

    Read More

  • The War within The War by Timothy Findley

    1727 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Struggles in life is something everyone is faced with whether it is physical, emotional mental or personal struggles. These struggles are capable of shaping an individual’s personality and outlook on life. Timothy Findley’s novel The Wars, shows that struggles lead to the character’s ultimate inner struggles, outer struggles and self-discovery. War exists in a person’s physical and psychological aspects. In The Wars, Robert Ross goes to war and fights a personal and physical battle.

    Read More

More about Book Review of "The Return of Martin Guerre"

Open Document