Beowulf Comparison Essay

825 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Literary devices in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight

Although from two different time periods in history and in literature, the epic poem, Beowulf, translated by Burton Raffel, and the medieval poem, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, translated by Marie Borroff, both contain parallel elements as well as conflicting ones. These include their motive for why they risk their lives to go into battle, the good deeds that they accomplish along the way, and the wrongs that they correct in the end.
All characters have some sort of motive for doing something; however, that motive depends on the type of person they are and the type of person they want to be. Beowulf, a brave warrior, comes from a powerful ancestry with Edgetho, a famous soldier, being his father, and Higlac, Lord of the Geats, being his uncle. Beowulf, also being loved by the Geats for protecting and fighting for them, makes the journey to Denmark in hope to help Hrothgar kill Grendel. His motive is not only to protect the innocent people who have been suffering for years, but to also show how great and fearless he really is. This is shown when he gives his first speech where he talks himself up by saying, “ ‘They have seen my strength for themselves/ have watched me rise from the darkness of war/ dripping with my enemies blood…death was my errand and the fate they had earned,’ ” (Raffel 47-48 246-253). While Beowulf’s motive is partly for self-gain and recognition, Sir Gawain’s motive is directed only towards others. Sir Gawain is just one of the many knights at the round table, who at first, does not come forth to take the foreign Green Knights offer. When King Arthur eventually steps up in order to defend his people, Sir Gawain steps in to protect his king. He himself knows that his life means nothing in comparison to the ...

... middle of paper ...

... “ ‘I confess, knight, in this place/ Most dire is my misdeed/ Let me gain back your good grace/ And thereafter I shall take heed,’ ” (Borroff 183 474-477). Gawain is given back the girdle, the one that caused damage to the person who he strives to be, and this shows that he is able to live up to his mistakes and correct them so he will not commit them again.
Beowulf and Sir Gawain have many aspects, such as their motives, good deeds, and correcting of wrongs, in common. Many, however, seem to differ because of the type of person they are, want to be, and their drive in life. Beowulf is more self-centered yet helps those who support him while Sir Gawain protects others while having to fix the wrongs in himself. Throughout history and literature, whether ancient, classic, or modern, the idea of a perfect hero is so remote, due to their individualities as a person.

Show More
Related

  • Compare And Contrast The Hero And Beowulf

    1023 Words  | 3 Pages

    What is hero? A hero, under the Merriam-Webster definition, is a person who is admired for brave/great acts or fine qualities. This is a very broad definition that combines both ancient and modern belief of what --or who-- a hero should be. Beowulf is an epic poem that focuses on an Anglo-Saxon hero. As such he embodies the traits that his culture valued most. Deadpool, on the other hand, portrays the most recent ideas of what traits a hero should embody. With these examples from contrasting periods, we are still able to see similarities and differences that shows how modern and Anglo-Saxon idea of heroism reflects its culture.

    Read More

  • Comparing the Hero in Beowulf and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight

    924 Words  | 2 Pages

    Heroes come in many forms. The construction of "the heroic" has taken many forms, yet traits such as: courage, honor, and loyalty, reappear as themes throughout the "hero" personality. The characters of Beowulf and Sir Gawain each represent a version of a hero, yet each comes across quite differently in their story. A hero can be said to truly win if he remains constant to his noble values when put in any situation that crosses his way. When measured by that criterion, Sir Gawain stands out above Beowulf as a true hero, due to his command of both personal and spiritual power through the use of thought, as well as valiant deeds.

    Read More

  • A Comparison of Perfection in Beowulf and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight

    1074 Words  | 3 Pages

    The heroes of both Beowulf and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight are fighters. However, the traits they have in common are far less numerous than those that set them apart. As each of the two is dubbed perfect by his contemporaries, it should be possible to draw the picture of both the model warrior and the paragon knight by comparing Beowulf and Gawain.

    Read More

  • Sir Gawain vs Beowulf

    2062 Words  | 5 Pages

    Initially, Gawain’s strongest trait is humility, Beowulf’s is pride. In the beginning of Gawain and the Green Knight, a mysterious warrior enters King Arthur’s court to extend a challenge. Although he knows others in the court would handle the challenge better than him, out of respect, when King Arthur attempts to accept the challenge Gawain comes forth and suggests he takes his place. Gawain presents himself as “the weakest of them, I know, and the dullest-minded/ so my death would be least loss, if truth should be told/ only because you are my uncle am I to be praised/ no virtue I know in myself but your blood” (Broadview Analogy 269). Instead of bragging about his bravery, Gawain acts modestly and states that his death would be of little loss during this challenge. He is not self-absorbed and gives off the impression that the only reason he is a knight is because of his relation with King Arthur. By stating this, he gives off the impression that his self confidence is quite weak; this is astonishing for a character of this era. Although King Arthur has at least one of his knights to be proud of, it seems as though

    Read More

  • Similarities And Differences And Challenges In The Tale Of Beowulf

    944 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout the story, Beowulf fights three battles against frightening monsters. Beowulf, the prince of the Geats, was a well known warrior with extreme strength who makes a promise to protect his people under any circumstance. In the poem, his strength is tested, but he uses it to save many people in battles against: Grendel, Grendel 's mother, and a dragon. Before, during, and after each of these battles Beowulf shows many similarities and differences in his actions.

    Read More

  • Beowulf A Hero Essay

    768 Words  | 2 Pages

    A hero is someone who is admired for their courage and bravery, as well as their noble accomplishments. They are respected by almost everyone, due to their kindness and charitable mindset, that drives them to fight for the good of others. Beowulf is the perfect representation of a hero, based on multiple characteristics that he displays throughout the novel. Along with his characteristics, Beowulf also takes on many “hero like” challenges and tasks. In the novel, Beowulf is praised and admired throughout the kingdom for his bravery, humility, and selflessness.

    Read More

  • Sir Gawain And The Green Knight Deception Analysis

    507 Words  | 2 Pages

    Of all the themes in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, the one which stood out the most to me was that of deception. With the Green Knight, the “evil” and Sir Gawain, the “good”, we see both forces partake in deceptive practices to achieve the desired outcome they sought. Throughout the poem, Sir Gawain’s moral compass was constantly being tested with deception being used to gage his level of loyalty, morality, and chivalry. The “game” that the Green Knight was hell bent on playing was not an honest one. He utilized a host of deceptions to gain the results that he sought after—there was little to no room for error with him. First, he presented a challenge in which he alone knew that he would not perish. When he asked for a volunteer to strike him with the ax, the Green Knight

    Read More

  • Knight's Hypocrisy In Sir Gawain And The Green Knight

    720 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Sir Gawain humbly approaches the King and courageously says, “For I find it not fit… when such a boon is begged… though you be tempted… to take in on yourself while so bold men about upon benches sit” (122-125) “And for that this folly befits a king, and ‘tis I that have asked it, it ought to be mine” (132-133). He, the weakest Knight, sees the injustice of someone challenging the King and instead of acting passively he willingly sacrifices himself for the King’s sake, which shows his loyalty, courage and integrity. However, Sir Gawain becomes a hypocrite even though the Green Knight says, “Friend mine, it seems your word holds good” (333-334) because the Green Knight’s wife “made trial of a man most faultless by far” (452) and he did not remain loyal and honest. The opportunity of remaining secure and safe presents itself and selfishly he chooses this course of action; consequently, he “lacked… a little in loyalty there” (456). In the end, the Green Knight reprimands him for his dishonesty and lack of integrity and in return Sir Gawain, shamefully responds “I confess, knight, in this place, most dire is my misdeed; let me gain back your good grace…” (Line 474-476) so even though he was not noble and loyal throughout the entire course he remains sincere in his apology. His loyalty to the King in the

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Sir Gawain And The Code Of Chivalry

    1645 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Green Knight’s speech shows this whole challenge is to test the reputation of King Arthur’s court, and Sir Gawain was motivated and willing to uphold this reputation no matter his skill. Once again, the Knight’s motivation is more so on his on survival, while Sir Gawain’s motivation is based on upholding King Arthur’s reputation.

    Read More

  • A Comparison of Beowulf and Sir Gawain

    802 Words  | 2 Pages

    Beowulf and Gawain are shown as great leaders. Sir Gawain is liked by most people he has met. Beowulf has many loyal followers by his side. Beowulf and Sir Gawain are both brave and loyal. They attempt to honor their kings and kingdoms. Those are all qualities of a hero.

    Read More

  • Sir Gawain And The Green Knight Analysis

    1838 Words  | 4 Pages

    The title characters in both Beowulf and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight were both considered paragons of excellence by their peoples. Yet, upon close inspection of the specific actions of these characters, stark differences emerge. While Gawain is virtuous and exemplifies selflessness, Beowulf's heroism is marred by his pursuit of fame and wealth, which seems to dominate his every action. The discrepancy can be explained by a contextual analysis of both heroes. Gawain's code of chivalry emphasizes perfection and thus he is flawless.

    Read More

  • Beowulf Similarities And Differences

    371 Words  | 1 Pages

    There are many similarities and differences between each battle Beowulf is part of. In every battle, the reader expects Beowulf to be victorious since it has been stated since the beginning of the epic poem that he is a hero. In addition to this Beowulf’s intention is the same in every battle. Although he would argue that he wants to destroy Grendel in order to help Heorot, it is clear Beowulf only wants to build a strong reputation for himself. I personally thought Beowulf had a very arrogant personality especially when it came to fighting battles for his own benefit rather than the people. Some key differences found in each battle is how Beowulf goes about defeating the monsters and the dragon. In the battle with Grendel Beowulf fights without

    Read More

  • Comparing Beowulf and a Modern-Day Hero

    402 Words  | 1 Pages

    This essay is the comparison between Beowulf and a modern day hero. I consider any American soldier to be my modern day hero. In this essay I will explain in three paragraphs of how my modern day hero is like Beowulf. With in these three paragraphs I will go over how they are both fighting for a good cause, how they are both rewarded for what they do, and how they are both treated with much respect.

    Read More

  • Beowulf narrative essay

    566 Words  | 2 Pages

    Beowulf is a very brave hero, he has fought and killed many creatures before, but this battle was different. He knew this battle was of great importance to everyone, and that made him that much more nervous. This creature was fierce and had been tormenting their village for as long as they could remember, so her death would be a huge victory for Beowulf and it would be an even bigger relief for the villagers. All of the people in the village were cheering for Beowulf as he walked away headed off to the greatest battle of his life.

    Read More

  • Modern Heroes: Dante Vs. Beowulf

    977 Words  | 2 Pages

    Erika Mercado Essay 2 Modern Heroes: Dante vs Beowulf A modern hero is a good-hearted person with these attributes: bravery, strong, and contributes to saving the lives of his homelands. Beowulf demonstrates the characteristics of a modern hero: a leader, fearless, and generous. Beowulf is a young hero whose character exerts powerful strength in battles. Dante the Pilgrim does not display hero attributes in The Inferno.

    Read More

More about Beowulf Comparison Essay

Open Document