Ashraf Rushdy's Confessions Of Nat Turner

2492 Words5 Pages

Ashraf Rushdy notes that the Neo-slave narrative genre as a whole began to come about as a response to William Styron’s book Confessions of Nat Turner. This novel sparks the conversation regarding who should be able to retell these histories, and Rushdy notes one of the most precarious aspects of Styron’s novel: “its presumption of assuming the voice of a slave, its uninformed appropriation of African American culture, its deep, almost conservative allegiance to the traditional historiographical portrait of slavery” (4). Madhu Dubey also notes that the genre “was preceded by a heightened public attention to slavery during the late 1960’s. . . . Conflicts over how slavery should be represented in the realms of historiography, literature, and …show more content…

Scarry informs us that “A great deal . . . is at stake in the attempt to invent linguistic structures that will reach and accommodate this area of experience normally so inaccessible to language; the human attempt to reverse the de-objectifying work of pain by forcing pain itself into avenues of objectification is a project laden with practical and ethical consequence” (6). She argues that because pain obliterates language and thought, the language people attempt to create to expresses the experience is often inadequate. But, genres such as the slave narrative and the neo-slave narrative problematize Scarry’s arguments by pointing to the fact that a usable language can be created from pain, and often this language takes form in the shape of metaphors, similes, and analogies. Though Scarry argues that language does not effectively articulate pain, slave narratives have done a remarkable job of articulating the experience of enslaved black people. Authors such as Frederick Douglass and Harriet Ann Jacobs, who have written slave narratives, not only effectively created the language they needed to articulate their experiences, but they show how in their most intense moments of pain, knowledge can be born. For example, Frederick Douglass discusses how he was beaten daily under the care of one of his overseers, Covey. During these beatings, thought was not obliterated; instead, Douglass was able to establish a new epistemology about slavery. This pain created a clear knowledge of how violence and brutal workloads were used to break a human and make a willing and “mindless” slave, and he was to convey this knowledge later in his own slave

Open Document