Argumentative Essay On Flavored Milk

1875 Words4 Pages

Flavored milk, such as chocolate milk is designed to be a tastier alternative to plain milk. In 1942, chocolate milk only accounted for “2.2 percent of the total fluid milk consumption in [U.S.] cities and villages” (Hadary 210-213) However, as of 2009, “...flavored milks [in U.S schools such as strawberry and chocolate milk] account for seventy percent (emphasis added) of all the milk [children] drink” (Lunau 48), with chocolate milk accounting for around sixty-two percent of all milk (Hanks, Just, and Wansink) . Flavored milk’s popularity in the United States is controversial, given the fact that chocolate milk contains added sugar to make it have “roughly [the same amount of sugar] as a glass of orange juice” (Lunau 48). Currently, there …show more content…

According to the New York City Department of Education, “school milk [which includes chocolate milk] is an important source of protein, calcium, and vitamins such as A and D” ("Effects of Switching from Whole to Low-Fat/Fat-Free Milk in Public Schools � New York City, 2004�2009."70-73). All of these nutrients are commonly thought to be necessary for children, especially during their growth and development phases. As one of the most important minerals in the human body, calcium maintains a healthy bone-density as well as allows muscles to contract and helping nerves send messages through the body (Aceto 246+). In addition, vitamin A found in chocolate milk is vital to human intellectual development of people. A study conducted at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies in 2006 examined the hippocampus tissue of mutant mice with a deficiency in vitamin A. Interestingly, the study concluded that a deficiency of vitamin A in mice broke important brain functions. More specifically, the deficiency “impaired LTP (long-term potentiation) and LTD (long-term depression) processes”(J.T. 360). The presence of these processes are very important as they are indicators of proper “connections between brain cells” (J.T. 360). Even though this study was limited to mice, it still demonstrates that vitamin A is important in humans as it helps fend off “learning and memory …show more content…

Dr. James Rippe, a Harvard Medical School graduate and professor at the University of Central Florida, “[dismisses the] claim [that] high fructose syrups in flavored milk [cause obesity] in children” ("Amid Bans at U.S. Schools, Research Highlights the Health Benefits of Chocolate Milk."). Since childhood obesity is a relatively new, complex phenomenon, we cannot jump the gun and blame added sugar. Dr. Rippe believes that HFCS is nutritionally the same as healthy sugars extracted from beets and canes, and therefore, chocolate milk cannot cause obesity.("Amid Bans at U.S. Schools, Research Highlights the Health Benefits of Chocolate Milk."). In addition, a study conducted in Canadian elementary schools from 1992 to 2002 noticed that the estimated contribution of added sugars from [flavored] milk, derived from per capita availability data, is low at <1 g/day, or ~1% of Canadians' total added sugars intake” (Henry 3). This study emphasizes that the added sugar in chocolate milk is not enough to cause the obesity epidemic in

Open Document