Analytical Essay

664 Words2 Pages

The construction last year of a shopping mall in downtown Oak City was a

mistake. Since the mall has opened, a number of local businesses have closed, and the

downtown area suffers from an acute parking shortage. Arrests for crime and vagrancy

have increased in nearby Oak City Park. Elm City should pay attention to the example of

the Oak City Mall and deny the application to build a shopping mall in Elm City.

Analyzing this argument brings up a lot of questions to whether this is a relevant

argument or not. A lot of assumptions are made without enough facts to support them. It

can be said that the mall could have directly or indirectly been a part of the problems.

The problems are: Increase in crime and vagrancy, businesses closing, and a parking

shortage. It is not logical to say that it is sole cause of the situation.

This argument states that the building of the mall is the reason that some

businesses have went out of business. To say that the mall and the closes of the

businesses go hand in hand is not totally accurate.

There are a number of reasons that could have led to the closing of the businesses.

For one example, you could say that a change in the economy might have led to the

closures. If this occurred after the holidays, it could say that people spent most of their

money during this time and it could have hurt some businesses beyond the point of

repair. Also, this argument doesn?t state what kinds of businesses had troubles. If it was

something as in a grocery store, the mall could not be the cause because the mall doesn?t

interfere directly with the food industry.

Also, a majority of small businesses succumb to larger ones. This area is not

exempt to the possibilities that this is what could have happened. This argument does not

state if mergers of smaller companies related to the statement.

The argument tries to tie together that a parking shortage was caused by the Oak

City Mall. While in turn the mall would bring increased foot traffic, it would also bring

along more commerce to the city, thus businesses should not have struggled as previously

mentioned. A number of factors could have added to the parking shortage. With most

communities now, population increases every year.

Open Document