Analysis Of The Secret Diaries Of Miss Anne Lister

1586 Words4 Pages

Until their deciphering in the 1980’s, the diaries of eighteenth century landowner Anne Lister were an unknown tome of lesbian history. Written largely in a cipher of Lister’s conception, The Secret Diaries of Miss Anne Lister detail not only her day to day routine and superficial social interactions, but also the complexities of her romantic and sexual relationships with women, precise tailoring of her appearance, harassment she faced due to her gender non-conformity, and biting commentary on those in her social circles. Contained in plain hand, legible to anyone who may have come across Lister’s diaries with prying eyes, is documentation of her life in both York and Halifax such as the day’s weather, meals she took with neighboring families, …show more content…

Not only did Lister dress in masculine fashion, but cropped her hair close to her head, a complete departure from feminine fashion of the period. While Lister’s appearance, along with her confident gait and low voice, register as masculine, causing social backlash towards Lister, her status affords her the social mobility to present herself in whichever manner she pleases. On this matter, the translator and editor of The Secret Diaries of Miss Anne Lister, Helena Whitbread states, “Her position in life…enabled her to construct her own identity in defiance of social and cultural norms,” a statement that resounds through the entirety of Lister’s experience, including her ability to emulate masculine presentation (Whitbread …show more content…

Told her that, for this reason, I always wore black” (Lister 184). Although Lister consistently presents herself as confident in her appearance, both when interacting with others and in her diaries, this interaction points to discomfort with her non-normative presentation. Confrontational interactions on a routine basis most likely had and inevitable impact on her self-perception — Lister frequently became the target of verbal and physical harassment, predominately from men, when she simply ran errands or walked through town. In one instance Lister recorded “The people generally remark, as I pass along, how much I am like a man. I think they did it more than usual this evening. At the top of Cunnery Lane, as I went, three men said, as usual, ‘That’s a man’ & one axed ‘Does your cock stand?’” (61). Immediately after relaying this incident, the succeeding line states in plain hand “I know not how, but I feel low this evening” (61). In the face of verbal harassment, Lister is visibly negatively impacted, but the true extent of its effect on her is only understood by an audience able to read both plain and crypt hand. Due to this diary entry’s inherent expectation of privacy, it’s assumed that no one aside from Lister herself would have access to the text, but nonetheless,

Open Document