Analysis Of Knighthood By Shirley Marchalonis

722 Words2 Pages

Shirley Marchalonis talks about knighthood and how it was, originally, a reward for someone who proved their valor on the battlefield. It was also a very religious ceremony and a complete way of life that was performed and affirmed by the church, which explains how violence was okay as long as it was done for the benefit of Christianity. Marchalonis points out that many of his early crimes seemed to be directly against the church, thus proving him to be a false and unworthy knight. She argues that the purpose of his penance was to humble his pride, saying that he was degraded in the court of an Emperor instead of in solitude. Marchalonis then mentions Sir Gowther’s gaining of knighthood and the meaning behind the different colored horses he …show more content…

Adler then talks about how this piece breaks these gender norms by making the women of the story, arguably more important than that of the male figures of the court. It is not only the man-dog bond that it is important in this story, but also the female-canine bond, as we see many times with the princess and her hounds. She argues that the Duke’s assumption of his wife’s infertility and the devil’s fatherly intercession suggest male inadequacy and corruption, as well as the idea that patriarchy can be sterilizing or the source of monstrosity. Adler also mentions that Sir Gowther and Merlin are half brothers by means of the same demon …show more content…

The source also argues for my question of nature vs. nurture and the fact that it was also his upbringing that turned him into a monster. It also argues the true importance of the woman-dog influence on Sir Gowther and the fact that his penance was about more than just his pride. The mention of Merlin is relevant because they have the same demon brother in them, but only one grows up to go on a horrible killing spree. Wright, Glenn. “Christianity and Romance in Medieval England”, English Studies, 93:1, 106-107. 2012. DOI: 10.1080/0013838X.2011.638447 Glenn Wright focuses first on Sir Gowther’s birth and how the demon was able to seduce the mother and procreate this “demon” child with her. It seems to be saying that the mother was at fault here for who Sir Gowther is “destined” to become. Wright then goes into detail about his penance and especially on the fact that God granted him the means to become the emperor-host’s champion, not once, but three different times which, in turn, also allows Sir Gowther to marry his daughter and become heir to the estate and the title that comes with it. He also mentions how the acceptability of the violence shifted as Sir Gowther was now violent in the name of Christianity as opposed to in allegiance with his inner demon

Open Document