Ambiguity In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter

890 Words2 Pages

Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter - a story about relationships, love, and sin - takes place in 1640, Puritan Boston. During that time, laws were considerably stricter and punishments were more severe. Two of the principal characters, Hester Prynne and Arthur Dimmesdale, have committed adultery with each other, but face the punishments in different ways. Their mutual sin is the main focus of the novel. Society knows about Hester’s act of adultery from the beginning; however, Dimmesdale tries to mask his sin from society, and the internal guilt he faces becomes unbearable. Through the suffering and struggles both these characters face, readers are able to understand the multiple themes of the novel. The themes of individual versus society, …show more content…

Hester is largely affected by the uncertainty of how society should perceive her and believes she “can change her human nature and make up for what she is and has done” (12). However, even after her public penance, society questions whether Hester has truly redeemed herself (Morey 77). The community is also unclear on how Hester feels about her scarlet letter. When she elaborately embroidered it, some were “outraged that she has made a mockery of her punishment by making this plain symbol of adultery into a gorgeous decoration” (Johnson 10). Others argued that it portrayed her creativity as a seamstress and viewed the letter as a symbol of her artistic nature (11). The physical scarlet letter is a vital part of the novel, and readers soon recognize that Dimmesdale also carries a scarlet letter on his chest, but questions whether it is physical or mental (12). Due to his overwhelming need to free his spirit from the internal guilt he has built up over the years, Dimmesdale does what he can to relieve his shameful feelings. He frequently holds his hand over his chest, implying that he too is carrying a scarlet letter (Johnson 16). When Dimmesdale finally acknowledges his sin and reveals himself to society as the father of Hester’s child, his sin is still unclear to some members of the community. At his

Open Document