Amanda in The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams

737 Words2 Pages

Amanda in The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams After reading The Glass Menagerie I would tend to agree with this comment for a number of reasons that I shall discuss in this essay, but do not agree with it completely, and feel there are a number of significant reasons as to why Amanda behaves in the way she does, and I plan to discuss this too. To begin with, throughout the play, Amanda constantly talks about the abundance of gentlemen callers she used to receive in her youth. This annoys her son and, I would suggest, embarrasses her daughter who has never has a gentleman caller. I do not think she talks about these men in order to bring out these feelings in her children, and may indeed be as a way of 'returning to' her youth by remembering the way she acted in her past. However, it seems strange to me that, just because she does reminisce her past, we should conclude that she is desperate to return to youth. I would argue that everyone thinks back to the good times in their life, especially if they are having a hard time in their present, as certainly Amanda is doing. I do not agree, therefore, on this fact that she is desperately trying to relive her youth. Indeed, it seems to me that she is simply telling her children the only story she has from her youth. Another argument against the comment made is that, surely, if Amanda was trying to relive her youth, she would still be desperate to receive her own gentlemen callers, or be out trying to find them. My point is simply that she does not appear interested in having any of her own gentlemen callers. However she does, indeed, seem desperate for her daughter to receive... ... middle of paper ... ... ignore, such as her flirtatious behaviour with Jim, wearing her teenage dresses, and constantly talking about her past. I would however argue, on the grounds of the points I have made, that Amanda is not trying to relive her youth. She is actually reliving her good times, in a time of hardship in her life, and trying to find a way of communicating with her children. Consequently I do not agree with the comment that 'Amanda is trying to relive her youth' as I feel the underlying reasons are far more important in understanding why she appears to be trying to relive her youth, rather than the simple fact that she behaves immaturely for her age, and that her unhappiness, loneliness and misunderstanding of her children are the main factors that led to her behaviour, rather than a simple desire to return to her youth.

Open Document