A Comparison Of Sir Gawain And The Carl Of Carlisle

1243 Words3 Pages

Texts such as Sir Gawain and the Carl of Carlisle helped transform knights from a brutal killing squad to more of what we envision knights to be today. At the beginning of the Middle Ages, knights more closely resembled a medieval mafia. They were not men in shining armor that rode a white horse and killed a dragon to save the princess. Knights started as Comitatus, a brotherhood based around battling and killing for good stuff. This brotherhood did not have a defined enemy and killed anyone who different from them. As time progressed and the idea of feudalism came into action, Comitatus developed into a lord and vassal relationship. While Comitatus had one head warrior that divided the good stuff they earned, vassals had lords that would …show more content…

Another example is how they treat the Carl's foul in the story. Kay believes the foul should not feed with his horse because it is not good enough. He kicks it out of the barn and strikes it. The Carl punishes him by knocking him out. On the other hand, Gawain brings the foul back into the stable and allows it to eat alongside his horse, the Carl rewards Gawain for respecting his foul. In the end, Gawain followed all the Carl's wishes and was rewarded with the most beautiful girl, the amie. This showed knights the benefits of leaving behind their old ways to become a soldier of Christ. Sir Kay is not the only example of what a good knight should not be. The Carl of Carlisle is also a representation of how knights should not act. The Carl is the opposite of chivalric and uncivilized. In the text, the Carl is described as a large and scary man. “Nine tailor's yards he was high/with long and powerful legs”(Gawain,8 ). The Carl also is surrounded by a zoo of animals. There was lion, a bear, a lethal boar, and a wild bull; all obeyed and feared the Carl. This shows how barbarian and dangerous the Carl can …show more content…

Number 18 of the Art of Courtly Love is, “Good character alone makes any man worthy of love”(Capellanus). Number 14 says, “The easy attainment of love makes it of little value; difficulty of attainment makes it prized”(Capellanus). As mentioned earlier, Sir Gawain represents how the government wants knights to act. He possesses the character traits of a good knight such as obedience, loyalty, honor, and being humble. Gawain also worked hard to be rewarded his the Carl's daughter. He treats the Carl and his porter with courtesy and treats the Carl's foul kindly as if it were his own. Finally, Gawain follows the Carl's orders to throw a spear at this Carl's face before sitting for dinner and to kiss the Carl's

Open Document