A Comparison Of Edward Manet's Olympia And The Olympia

679 Words2 Pages

A lot of the paintings done around the 1800 and 1900’s were expected to sell to higher-class citizens that targeted more of a male audience. While Edward Manet’s, Olympia seems to do just that, it actually takes a different turn than what his predecessors, Titian and Giorgione to be exact, with the same pose are doing. There the models in the paintings are depicted as goddesses whereas with Olympia the model has become the goddess herself. What’s even more controversial is when Yasumasa Morimura makes his own Olympia and titles it Portrait (Futago), and puts his own body into the painting saying that he is now the goddess. These two paintings have many similarities overall, but the main issue that both are trying to get the viewer to see is the reality of this world where you don’t see in earlier reclining nude paintings.
In Manet’s painting Olympia the viewer is faced with two women, one white and one black. The black woman is hunched over and handing flowers to the white woman who looks to be of upper class origin but could also be lower class. This woman is reclined on a bed and propped up by some pillows with a black cat standing at the end of the bed looking at the viewer as well. She, like her cat, looks out at the viewer with indifference that both shocks and pulls in the viewer. While the black woman is dressed, the white woman is nude and wears only shoes, bracelets, a flower in her hair, and a ribbon necklace. The colors in this painting reflect the white woman’s personality as well, cold and unfeeling.
In Yasumasa Morimura painting, Portrait (Futago) the viewer is faced with two people who are of different skin colors. However, instead of painting a woman in the reclining position, Morimura has put himself in this posi...

... middle of paper ...

...n imagine yourself in that place and in that position. Since we cannot act this out, Morimura has put himself into the painting to act out this sequence and to show what it would look like. This action has humanized the painting as a whole because it shows that he is an everyday person acting this out just like the woman in Olympia. Also the fact that he is a guy acting this out makes this just as scandalous as Olympia because it’s a nude man who is looking at you like the courtesan woman is in Olympia.
Although there are many more comparisons that can be made, the idea of the real woman is the clearly the main idea of what Manet and Morimura wanted to say in these paintings. Even though Morimura may have dressed up as a girl to represents this he too is still saying that a real woman is confident in herself and that everybody has flaws, which will never change.

Open Document