A Brief Comparison Of Giovanni's Room And Invisible Man

1014 Words3 Pages

Morgan’s deconstruction of the effects of white determinism as it pertains to the characters of black naturalist literary works is very reminiscent of Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man. Also, despite the supposed absence of black characters, James Baldwin’s Giovanni’s Room is an additional narrative that can be considered a black or an urban naturalist text. Many scholars argue that in actuality Baldwin’s character Giovanni is in fact a masked black character who, like Ellison’s nameless narrator, falls victim to his environment leading to his unfortunate death. Whether or not these two literary works are considered, black naturalism, urban naturalism, or just simply naturalism, both Giovanni’s Room and Invisible Man depict the realities of many. …show more content…

From the thematic similarities in their writings, one could assume that both writers’ literature stemmed from the same influences and held the same purposes; however, James Baldwin and Ralph Ellison, regardless of their likeness in themes of writing, came from different settings which ultimately served as the basis for their writing. Ralph Ellison’s father, Louis Ellison, insisted that his son be named after the philosopher Ralph Waldo Emerson. The naming of his child after a classical writer of American literature displays Ralph Ellison’s apparent support of his endeavors in the humanities by his father. Ellison’s father was an essential individual in his life. Ellison spent time watching his father work as he delivered items such as ice and coal to local homes and businesses. Ellison’s father died when he was young, which left the Ellison family continuously scrambling to make ends meet. Despite the absence of his father, Ralph Ellison lived up to his name and became one of the most widely known authors in America with his novel, Invisible …show more content…

James Baldwin, a New York native, was raised with religion being the core of his household. At the age of fourteen, the author began to preach the Gospel. His step-father, David Baldwin, was a fellow preacher who raised the writer as his own; however, James Baldwin and his step-father had a tumultuous relationship (due to James Baldwin’s sexual orientation) causing the young writer to move out of his family home at age seventeen, relocating to another part of New York and then on to Paris. The evolving author’s sexuality not only took a toll in his personal life, but also had an effect in his adulthood. The National Public Radio website (npr.org) discuses the impact James Baldwin’s sexual orientation had in his mature life within an article entitled, “American Lives: James Baldwin, ‘Lifting the Veil.’” NPR quotes author Randall Kenan, writer of James Baldwin the Cross of Redemption Uncollected Writings, to illustrate the numerous adversities James Baldwin encountered as a homosexual man. According to the web article, “Baldwin was ‘mysteriously’ removed from the list of speakers for the March on Washington in August 1963… And when he tried to help the Black Panther Party in the 1970s, his sexual orientation was thrown up at him in very hurtful

Open Document